WEBVTT
1
00:00:02.640 --> 00:00:06.639
For our one hundredth episode of Terrifying and True, we're
2
00:00:06.719 --> 00:00:10.199
honoring our good buddy and listener, Wolf Dan with his
3
00:00:10.320 --> 00:00:15.119
request to cover one of Ohio's most haunted unsolved crimes.
4
00:00:15.839 --> 00:00:19.039
In nineteen ninety six, twenty two year old Carrie Culberson
5
00:00:19.480 --> 00:00:23.519
vanished after a violent encounter with her ex. Her body
6
00:00:23.679 --> 00:00:27.839
was never found, but someone was still convicted of her murder.
7
00:00:28.640 --> 00:00:32.960
What you were about to take is burnt to be you?
8
00:00:34.479 --> 00:00:42.159
Based on witness accounts, testimonies, and public record. This is
9
00:00:44.000 --> 00:00:58.039
terrifying and true True Blanchester, Ohio, August twenty eighth, nineteen
10
00:00:58.200 --> 00:01:03.439
ninety six. And why at summer night, shattered by a scream,
11
00:01:04.239 --> 00:01:07.640
a young woman runs for her life beneath the glow
12
00:01:08.239 --> 00:01:14.200
of a street lamp, but she's never seen again. Twenty
13
00:01:14.239 --> 00:01:18.719
two year old Carrie Colberson vanished without a trace after
14
00:01:18.760 --> 00:01:24.120
a violent confrontation with her ex boyfriend. Her body was
15
00:01:24.200 --> 00:01:29.920
never found, her car gone, and yet a jury convicted
16
00:01:30.400 --> 00:01:34.400
her killer. What happened to Carrie? And why did local
17
00:01:34.439 --> 00:01:38.239
authorities seem to protect the suspect instead of the victim.
18
00:01:38.719 --> 00:01:41.519
For our one hundredth episode of Terrifying and True, we'll
19
00:01:41.519 --> 00:01:58.840
be telling that story After this, late August nineteen ninety six,
20
00:01:59.439 --> 00:02:04.400
blanchets to Ohio. A sticky summer night hangs over the
21
00:02:04.480 --> 00:02:10.800
sleepy small town street in the darkness just before midnight,
22
00:02:11.520 --> 00:02:17.960
A sudden scream pierces the silence. Help me. A young
23
00:02:18.000 --> 00:02:24.840
woman's voice cries out, raw with terror. On a moonlit
24
00:02:24.919 --> 00:02:30.479
front lawn, a frantic figure, twenty two year old Carrie Culberson,
25
00:02:31.280 --> 00:02:37.639
is seen desperately running her silhouette, illuminated by a flickering
26
00:02:37.719 --> 00:02:43.319
street light. Chasing her is a man she knows all
27
00:02:43.400 --> 00:02:48.599
too well, her on and off boyfriend, twenty four year
28
00:02:48.639 --> 00:02:53.039
old Vincent Dowan. He catches up to her and grabs
29
00:02:53.080 --> 00:02:58.360
a fistful of her hair. Neighbors peering from their windows
30
00:02:58.479 --> 00:03:04.719
watch in alarm. As Carrie struggles. Dowan's voice, rough with rage,
31
00:03:05.199 --> 00:03:09.000
shatters the humid air. I told you if you ever
32
00:03:09.080 --> 00:03:14.080
tried to leave me, I'd kill you, he snarls. Carrie
33
00:03:14.159 --> 00:03:18.560
is pummeled with fists as she fights to break free.
34
00:03:19.039 --> 00:03:23.080
For a moment, her pleas for help cut through the night,
35
00:03:23.960 --> 00:03:29.439
and then, with a squeal of tires on asphalt, there
36
00:03:29.479 --> 00:03:34.759
is only silence. The little red Honda CRX they had
37
00:03:34.759 --> 00:03:41.479
been seen beside is now gone. Disappearing into the darkness.
38
00:03:42.960 --> 00:03:49.280
By dawn, Carrie Coulberson had vanished without a trace. Her
39
00:03:49.319 --> 00:03:53.840
family would awaken to an empty house and a nightmare
40
00:03:54.759 --> 00:04:00.319
that was just beginning. In the coming days, this at
41
00:04:00.319 --> 00:04:04.759
Ohio village would be plunged into a real life mystery
42
00:04:05.400 --> 00:04:11.319
worthy of the darkest crime drama, a mystery of love
43
00:04:11.520 --> 00:04:17.519
and violence, of a body that refused to surface, and
44
00:04:17.639 --> 00:04:22.839
of justice sought in the haunting absence of a victim.
45
00:04:24.120 --> 00:04:28.600
The story of Carrie's disappearance and the search for answers
46
00:04:29.319 --> 00:04:35.480
unfolds like a cinematic thriller. A beautiful young woman gone missing,
47
00:04:36.319 --> 00:04:41.959
a violent lover as the prime suspect, a town divided
48
00:04:42.439 --> 00:04:48.160
by secrets, and a determined family fighting for the truth
49
00:04:48.759 --> 00:04:55.399
in the face of unimaginable loss. Blanchester, Ohio is the
50
00:04:55.519 --> 00:05:02.720
kind of tight knit Midwestern town where everyone's seemingly knows everyone.
51
00:05:02.839 --> 00:05:08.439
In nineteen ninety six, its population hovered around four thousand,
52
00:05:08.560 --> 00:05:13.720
two hundred. A one stop like village amid the cornfields,
53
00:05:14.199 --> 00:05:19.560
about thirty five miles outside of Cincinnati, It's the sort
54
00:05:19.600 --> 00:05:25.519
of place that seemed safe, even idyllic, the kind of
55
00:05:25.600 --> 00:05:30.079
small town where parents felt comfortable letting their children ride
56
00:05:30.120 --> 00:05:35.120
bikes down sleepy streets, and where neighbors greet each other
57
00:05:35.519 --> 00:05:41.480
at the grocery store. Nothing bad ever happens here, people
58
00:05:41.639 --> 00:05:47.560
used to think, But Blanchester would soon learn that even
59
00:05:47.680 --> 00:05:55.439
in quiet towns, darkness can lurk behind closed doors. In
60
00:05:55.519 --> 00:06:01.800
this unassuming community, Carrie Coulberson was a loved figure with
61
00:06:01.879 --> 00:06:07.439
a warm smile and vibrant personality. Carrie was often described
62
00:06:07.519 --> 00:06:13.160
as truly someone special by those who knew her. She
63
00:06:13.319 --> 00:06:19.199
had big brown eyes, a cheerleader's energy, and homecoming queen looks,
64
00:06:19.680 --> 00:06:24.600
as one account later put it, In high school, Carrie
65
00:06:24.639 --> 00:06:28.879
had been everywhere. She served as a class officer and
66
00:06:29.000 --> 00:06:33.759
appeared on the homecoming court all four years, balanced by
67
00:06:33.879 --> 00:06:38.879
nine years as a cheerleader. She sang in the choir,
68
00:06:39.399 --> 00:06:44.000
played sports from soccer to volleyball, and even played the
69
00:06:44.000 --> 00:06:49.800
bells in the school band. After graduating in nineteen ninety two,
70
00:06:50.560 --> 00:06:55.439
Carrie explored college. She enrolled at the University of Cincinnati
71
00:06:56.160 --> 00:07:00.120
as a pre law student, but ultimately found her her
72
00:07:00.160 --> 00:07:06.680
passion closer to home, becoming a licensed nail technician. Ever ambitious,
73
00:07:07.120 --> 00:07:11.439
she hadn't given up on furthering her education In fact,
74
00:07:12.360 --> 00:07:16.519
the day before she disappeared, Carrie took a nursing school
75
00:07:16.560 --> 00:07:20.879
pre admission test at a local community college, hoping to
76
00:07:21.040 --> 00:07:27.959
launch a career in healthcare. By her early twenties, Carrie
77
00:07:28.040 --> 00:07:31.319
seemed to have the world at her feet. Friends and
78
00:07:31.439 --> 00:07:36.920
family remember her as bubbly, genuine and fun loving, the
79
00:07:37.040 --> 00:07:39.800
kind of young woman who could light up a room.
80
00:07:40.920 --> 00:07:45.560
She doated on her family, her mother, Deborah Culberson, her
81
00:07:45.560 --> 00:07:50.000
father Roger, and her younger sister Christina, often trying out
82
00:07:50.160 --> 00:07:53.600
new low fat recipes on her mom and little sister
83
00:07:54.199 --> 00:08:00.480
and joking about future domestic bliss. Quote. Well, the world
84
00:08:00.600 --> 00:08:04.839
needs little white picket fences, she would say with a laugh,
85
00:08:05.680 --> 00:08:11.519
dreaming of having her own happy family some day. Raised
86
00:08:11.560 --> 00:08:16.360
with confidence and strong willed by nature, Carrie wasn't someone
87
00:08:16.480 --> 00:08:21.600
anyone thought would fall into the trappings of an abusive relationship.
88
00:08:22.360 --> 00:08:25.279
That's why it was so shocking to those close to
89
00:08:25.360 --> 00:08:28.839
her when they began to see the signs of trouble
90
00:08:29.560 --> 00:08:35.200
with the man she was dating. Carrie met Vincent Dowan
91
00:08:35.679 --> 00:08:40.600
in the mid nineteen nineties, and at first their relationship
92
00:08:40.679 --> 00:08:45.639
seemed like a typical young romance, but it quickly spiraled
93
00:08:45.679 --> 00:08:51.600
into something dangerous. Vince was a local guy with a
94
00:08:52.120 --> 00:08:59.559
troubled reputation quote, violent, controlling, and prone to explosive jealousy,
95
00:09:00.159 --> 00:09:04.440
as friends would later describe him. Less than a year
96
00:09:04.519 --> 00:09:11.879
after they began dating, the abuse started and escalated very quickly.
97
00:09:19.039 --> 00:09:23.879
In one early incident, Doan smashed the windows of Carrie's
98
00:09:23.919 --> 00:09:30.159
car while she was sitting inside, glass, flying a terrifying
99
00:09:30.200 --> 00:09:36.840
outburst that foreshadowed worse to come soon. He was hitting
100
00:09:36.879 --> 00:09:40.879
her on at least one occasion so brutally that he
101
00:09:40.960 --> 00:09:45.320
bruised her kidneys. He would throw her across rooms in
102
00:09:45.399 --> 00:09:49.600
fits of rage. Friends saw Carrie turn up with black
103
00:09:49.639 --> 00:09:56.080
eyes and bruises trying to cover for Vince's violence. Her
104
00:09:56.120 --> 00:09:59.720
boss at the salon recalled how Carrie once came to
105
00:09:59.799 --> 00:10:04.080
work with finger shaped marks on her neck and a
106
00:10:04.080 --> 00:10:10.039
bruised temple, signs of strangulation and blows to the head.
107
00:10:11.600 --> 00:10:15.519
Dowan's violence peaked in the summer of nineteen ninety six,
108
00:10:16.440 --> 00:10:21.879
just weeks before Carrie went missing. In late July, during
109
00:10:21.919 --> 00:10:26.840
a dispute, Vince grabbed a heavy space heater and smashed
110
00:10:26.879 --> 00:10:31.120
it into the back of Carrie's head, splitting her scalp.
111
00:10:32.639 --> 00:10:37.480
She survived the assault, but needed five surgical staples in
112
00:10:37.600 --> 00:10:43.679
order to close the gash. This time, Carrie did something courageous.
113
00:10:44.879 --> 00:10:49.639
She filed a criminal complaint against Dowan for misdemeanor assault.
114
00:10:50.639 --> 00:10:53.360
It was not the first time she had gone to
115
00:10:53.399 --> 00:10:58.200
the police for help. At least three times prior she
116
00:10:58.279 --> 00:11:04.960
had reported Vince's abuse. Each time the response was tepid.
117
00:11:06.200 --> 00:11:13.159
Dowan somehow evaded arrest or serious investigation until Carrie herself
118
00:11:13.559 --> 00:11:18.799
pressed charges for the space heater attack. Finally, a court
119
00:11:18.879 --> 00:11:22.279
date was set. Vince Dowan was due in court on
120
00:11:22.360 --> 00:11:27.159
those assault charges the week after August twenty eighth, nineteen
121
00:11:27.240 --> 00:11:33.039
ninety six. For once, it seemed Carrie was standing up
122
00:11:33.279 --> 00:11:39.440
and the law would intervene, but Vince Dowan had other plans.
123
00:11:40.960 --> 00:11:45.600
Those close to Carrie later realized that leaving Vince was
124
00:11:45.639 --> 00:11:50.240
the most dangerous time for her. Quote every time she
125
00:11:50.320 --> 00:11:53.320
attempted to leave was when he would beat her and
126
00:11:53.399 --> 00:11:56.000
tell her if I can't have you, no one can.
127
00:11:56.840 --> 00:12:03.039
Her family recalled, threatened not just Carrie but also her
128
00:12:03.039 --> 00:12:07.919
loved ones, warning he'd hurt her mother or sister if
129
00:12:08.000 --> 00:12:13.759
Carrie ever broke up with him. He stalked her, controlled
130
00:12:13.799 --> 00:12:20.360
who she saw and even held her at gunpoint. In fact, chillingly,
131
00:12:21.240 --> 00:12:26.159
just a few days before Carrie disappeared, Dowan abducted her
132
00:12:26.879 --> 00:12:32.799
and held her captive for five hours at gunpoint. She
133
00:12:32.919 --> 00:12:37.279
eventually got away from that encounter with her life, but
134
00:12:37.399 --> 00:12:42.480
it was a sign that Vince's obsession was reaching a
135
00:12:42.559 --> 00:12:49.159
fever pitch. As one prosecutor would later theorize, Dowan was
136
00:12:49.320 --> 00:12:53.759
desperate to stop Carrie from testifying against him on the
137
00:12:53.799 --> 00:13:00.480
assault charges or from escaping his grasp once and for all.
138
00:13:02.000 --> 00:13:07.799
The stage was set for a tragedy. Carrie's friends and
139
00:13:07.919 --> 00:13:13.720
family were urging her to leave him for good, terrified
140
00:13:13.759 --> 00:13:20.200
by the abuse they'd witnessed. Carrie herself was afraid, but
141
00:13:20.279 --> 00:13:25.080
she seemed to be gathering the resolve to break free.
142
00:13:25.200 --> 00:13:30.399
In late August nineteen ninety six, despite her fear, she
143
00:13:30.600 --> 00:13:36.639
was planning to end the relationship for good. Vince apparently
144
00:13:36.840 --> 00:13:40.759
sensed it coming. He was not about to let Carrie go.
145
00:13:41.759 --> 00:13:45.960
In his mind, she was his, and if he couldn't
146
00:13:46.000 --> 00:13:51.799
control her, he'd make good on his threats. The darkness
147
00:13:51.840 --> 00:13:55.600
that had been building in their two year relationship was
148
00:13:55.679 --> 00:14:02.480
about to engulf them both When August twenty eighth, nineteen
149
00:14:02.639 --> 00:14:08.279
ninety six began as a normal day, brimming with late
150
00:14:08.399 --> 00:14:14.120
summer activity. That evening, Carrie joined her friends for a
151
00:14:14.120 --> 00:14:18.480
weekly ritual. She played in a co ed volleyball league
152
00:14:18.879 --> 00:14:24.399
in a town nearby called Morrow. Carrie loved sports, and
153
00:14:24.519 --> 00:14:27.720
the friendly game followed by a trip to a local bar,
154
00:14:28.480 --> 00:14:32.720
was something she always looked forward to. But that night,
155
00:14:33.440 --> 00:14:39.440
an uninvited visitor showed up at the sand courts, Vincent Dowan.
156
00:14:40.639 --> 00:14:45.960
He was angry, angry that Carrie hadn't come to see him,
157
00:14:46.320 --> 00:14:50.519
angry perhaps that she was spending time with others when
158
00:14:50.600 --> 00:14:56.600
he was facing legal trouble. According to Carrie's friend Jessica Williams,
159
00:14:56.919 --> 00:15:00.120
who was with her at the game, Dowan tried to
160
00:15:00.000 --> 00:15:03.679
to get Carrie to leave with him mid game, insisting
161
00:15:04.200 --> 00:15:09.159
she go with him, but she refused. On the surface,
162
00:15:09.759 --> 00:15:15.039
Carrie stayed calm, shaking her head no as Vince glowered
163
00:15:15.080 --> 00:15:19.240
at her from the sidelines. She had promised to drive
164
00:15:19.279 --> 00:15:23.440
her teammates home that night. She wasn't about to abandon
165
00:15:23.519 --> 00:15:29.080
them for him. Frustrated, Dowan peeled out of the parking
166
00:15:29.120 --> 00:15:35.080
lot tires, squealing and frustration. Jessica later recalled that after
167
00:15:35.159 --> 00:15:40.039
the game at Carrie's request, they drove by Doan's house
168
00:15:40.159 --> 00:15:44.840
in Blanchester a couple of times, perhaps to see if
169
00:15:44.879 --> 00:15:51.039
he was home or still fuming, before Jessica dropped Carrie
170
00:15:51.080 --> 00:15:54.840
off back at her house on West Main Street around
171
00:15:54.879 --> 00:16:02.120
eleven thirty pm. Blanchester's streets were and quiet at that hour.
172
00:16:02.919 --> 00:16:08.080
A neighbor, Kimberly Lanyard, was sitting on her porch enjoying
173
00:16:08.200 --> 00:16:12.720
the late summer night, and she saw Jessica's car pull up.
174
00:16:13.519 --> 00:16:17.759
It was about eleven forty five pm when Carrie stepped
175
00:16:17.759 --> 00:16:20.879
out in front of her home, said good night to
176
00:16:20.919 --> 00:16:28.240
her friend, and went inside. But within minutes Lanyard noticed
177
00:16:28.360 --> 00:16:35.480
something was strange. Carrie's red Honda CRX, a distinctive little
178
00:16:35.519 --> 00:16:40.919
two door car, backing out of the Culberson driveway. The
179
00:16:41.039 --> 00:16:47.320
car's headlights were off, which struck Lanyard as odd. She
180
00:16:47.519 --> 00:16:52.000
watched the dark car roll halfway down the block before
181
00:16:52.039 --> 00:16:56.879
its headlights flicked on and it drove off into the night.
182
00:16:58.440 --> 00:17:02.320
Carrie had just gotten home. Why was she leaving again
183
00:17:02.759 --> 00:17:09.440
so soon and in such a stealthy manner. Lanyard would
184
00:17:09.519 --> 00:17:14.279
later report this peculiar sight, not realizing at the time
185
00:17:15.000 --> 00:17:19.440
that Carrie herself might not have been behind the wheel.
186
00:17:20.920 --> 00:17:27.079
Around the same time, another neighbor across town was about
187
00:17:27.119 --> 00:17:39.640
to witness the chaos described in our opening scene. Billy
188
00:17:39.799 --> 00:17:44.200
Joe Brown lived across the street from Vincent Dowan's house.
189
00:17:45.240 --> 00:17:49.720
Sometime near twelve thirty am, as she was getting ready
190
00:17:49.759 --> 00:17:53.920
for bed, Brown was startled by the sounds of a
191
00:17:53.960 --> 00:17:59.119
commotion outside. She peeked out to see under the glow
192
00:17:59.240 --> 00:18:03.559
of a street land there was that same little red
193
00:18:03.680 --> 00:18:08.839
car parked near Dowan's home, and a man and woman
194
00:18:09.640 --> 00:18:15.480
in a heated struggle. Brown recognized Vince Doan. He was
195
00:18:15.519 --> 00:18:20.160
a familiar face she often saw across the way, and
196
00:18:20.440 --> 00:18:24.000
she recognized the woman with him as the young lady
197
00:18:24.319 --> 00:18:30.759
who visited him frequently, Carrie Coulberson. What Brown saw next
198
00:18:31.599 --> 00:18:37.799
was horrifying. Carrie was screaming for help and trying to flee,
199
00:18:37.880 --> 00:18:44.000
but Vince was on her, yelling furiously. Brown distinctly heard
200
00:18:44.160 --> 00:18:48.880
Carrie cry out help me, while Dowan was shouting something
201
00:18:49.039 --> 00:18:54.839
like I told you next time, I'd kill you. Brown
202
00:18:55.000 --> 00:19:00.519
watched as Vince dragged Carrie and struck her repeatedly, then
203
00:19:01.240 --> 00:19:06.640
a sudden silence, perhaps Carrie was forced into the car
204
00:19:07.880 --> 00:19:12.759
moments later, Brown heard the squeal of tires. By the
205
00:19:12.839 --> 00:19:18.680
time she looked out again, the street was empty, The
206
00:19:18.799 --> 00:19:25.400
red car and Carrie were gone. What happened in those
207
00:19:25.480 --> 00:19:30.839
fraught moments would become the subject of testimony and speculation,
208
00:19:32.000 --> 00:19:38.319
but one thing is certain. Carrie Culberson was never seen
209
00:19:38.400 --> 00:19:44.960
again after that night. Some time after midnight, she vanished,
210
00:19:45.720 --> 00:19:50.400
as if into thin air. When the sun rose on
211
00:19:50.480 --> 00:19:56.640
August twenty ninth, nineteen ninety six, Debbie Culberson since something
212
00:19:56.920 --> 00:20:01.440
was wrong. She noticed that Carrie's Honda was not in
213
00:20:01.480 --> 00:20:06.440
the driveway where it should be. Carrie always came home
214
00:20:06.480 --> 00:20:10.920
at night, and if she ever stayed elsewhere, she would call.
215
00:20:12.160 --> 00:20:16.720
Debbie's worry quickly turned to panic when she couldn't find
216
00:20:16.920 --> 00:20:24.160
Carrie anywhere. She began driving around town, retracing routes Carrie
217
00:20:24.319 --> 00:20:29.000
might have taken. Her first instinct was to drive straight
218
00:20:29.079 --> 00:20:34.359
to Vincent Dowan's house or to his father's place, somewhere
219
00:20:34.440 --> 00:20:38.759
where she might find her daughter. At Lawrence Baker's house,
220
00:20:38.960 --> 00:20:43.799
Vincent's father, Debbie found Vince and demanded to know if
221
00:20:43.839 --> 00:20:49.240
he had seen Carrie. Vince's answers that day would later
222
00:20:49.480 --> 00:20:56.880
raise every possible alarm bell. According to Debbie, the first
223
00:20:56.920 --> 00:21:02.000
time she asked, Vince claimed he hadn't seen Carrie in
224
00:21:02.119 --> 00:21:07.319
three days. That made no sense. He had shown up
225
00:21:07.359 --> 00:21:11.480
at her volleyball game just the evening prior, after all.
226
00:21:12.680 --> 00:21:18.160
When Debbie pressed him again later, Vince abruptly changed his story.
227
00:21:19.119 --> 00:21:22.839
Now he said Carrie had driven by his house around
228
00:21:22.880 --> 00:21:27.920
twelve thirty a m honking her horn, but he refused
229
00:21:27.960 --> 00:21:33.640
to come out. He claimed she was drunk. Carrie's friends
230
00:21:33.680 --> 00:21:37.720
would later insist she'd had at most one beer all
231
00:21:37.839 --> 00:21:44.240
night and she was far from intoxicated. This version still
232
00:21:44.279 --> 00:21:48.839
didn't square with Debbi. She confronted Vince a third time
233
00:21:48.960 --> 00:21:54.039
as the day wore on, and again he shifted his tail.
234
00:21:55.160 --> 00:21:59.720
This time, he admitted he did see Carrie around twelve thirty.
235
00:22:00.559 --> 00:22:04.200
He said she'd even come into his house wrapped in
236
00:22:04.279 --> 00:22:08.079
a towel from a shower he'd been taking, and that
237
00:22:08.160 --> 00:22:12.319
they had had an argument. Supposedly, he told her he
238
00:22:12.400 --> 00:22:16.799
didn't love her any more. He claimed. Carrie then sped
239
00:22:16.880 --> 00:22:23.640
off angrily in her car, never to return. Three stories
240
00:22:24.160 --> 00:22:31.400
in one day, each different. Debby's blood ran cold. She
241
00:22:31.559 --> 00:22:38.759
knew something was terribly wrong. As Thursday turned into Friday,
242
00:22:38.880 --> 00:22:43.119
with still no sign of Carrie or her car, the
243
00:22:43.200 --> 00:22:49.960
missing person's case took on increasing urgency. Carrie's family reported
244
00:22:50.000 --> 00:22:54.799
her missing to the Blanchester Police within hours of her vanishing.
245
00:22:56.039 --> 00:23:02.519
The investigation into Carrie's disappearance had now begun, but it
246
00:23:02.559 --> 00:23:07.039
would soon become apparent that the search for truth would
247
00:23:07.079 --> 00:23:14.000
be frustrated at nearly every turn. When a loved one disappears,
248
00:23:14.799 --> 00:23:20.440
every minute counts, But in Carrie Culberson's case, the initial
249
00:23:20.519 --> 00:23:30.000
police response was shockingly lackluster, even possibly compromised. Blanchester Police
250
00:23:30.079 --> 00:23:34.759
Chief Richard Peyton, the town's top lawman, happened to be
251
00:23:34.920 --> 00:23:40.119
a personal friend of the Dowan family. In those crucial
252
00:23:40.240 --> 00:23:45.920
early hours after Carrie went missing, Instead of immediately treating
253
00:23:46.039 --> 00:23:51.279
Vincent Dowan as a suspect and locking down potential crime scenes,
254
00:23:52.000 --> 00:23:58.200
Chief Peyton alerted the Dowan family. He privately warned Vincent's father,
255
00:23:58.359 --> 00:24:03.920
Lawrence Baker, that Vincent would inevitably be a suspect in
256
00:24:04.039 --> 00:24:08.680
Carrie's disappearance. It was a heads up that gave the
257
00:24:08.759 --> 00:24:16.960
Dowans time to prepare, or perhaps to hide evidence. Carrie's
258
00:24:17.039 --> 00:24:22.839
family and friends, meanwhile, were not sitting idle. They fanned
259
00:24:22.880 --> 00:24:29.400
out across town, posting flyers and pleading for information. The
260
00:24:29.440 --> 00:24:33.519
whole community was on alert for the missing red Honda
261
00:24:33.680 --> 00:24:40.400
CRX or any sign of Carrie. Have you seen this girl?
262
00:24:40.519 --> 00:24:45.200
Posters with Carrie's smiling face went up in shop windows.
263
00:24:46.200 --> 00:24:51.920
Tips and rumors began to trickle in, some plausible, some
264
00:24:52.359 --> 00:24:59.039
utterly outlandish. One ghastly local rumor even suggested that Carrie
265
00:24:59.480 --> 00:25:04.680
had been fed to a lion that supposedly guarded the
266
00:25:04.720 --> 00:25:11.680
Dowan's junkyard, a horrifying notion that underscored the desperation and
267
00:25:12.599 --> 00:25:18.599
dark imagination swirling around the case. Amid the swirl of theories,
268
00:25:19.039 --> 00:25:24.799
one thing was clear. All roads of suspicion led to
269
00:25:24.960 --> 00:25:37.160
Vincent Dowan and his family's properties. Within five days of
270
00:25:37.319 --> 00:25:45.279
Carry's disappearance, investigators, under pressure from Carry's family and county authorities,
271
00:25:46.079 --> 00:25:50.920
finally honed in on the Dowan homestead on Hunt Road,
272
00:25:51.400 --> 00:25:57.160
a rural property owned by Vincent's father. There, behind a
273
00:25:57.200 --> 00:26:02.839
cluster of trees lay a murcury pond. Acting on a tip,
274
00:26:03.400 --> 00:26:07.920
and perhaps guided by the sickening intuition that a body
275
00:26:08.079 --> 00:26:13.319
might be hidden under the water, authorities brought in search dogs.
276
00:26:14.559 --> 00:26:17.480
The dogs hit on a scent at the edge of
277
00:26:17.519 --> 00:26:23.440
the pond, strongly indicating Carrie's body could be in or
278
00:26:23.480 --> 00:26:30.799
around that water. On September third, nineteen ninety six, the
279
00:26:30.880 --> 00:26:35.160
decision was made to drain the pond to see what
280
00:26:35.359 --> 00:26:41.680
secrets it might hold. What happened next would become one
281
00:26:41.720 --> 00:26:47.400
of the most contentious aspects of the case. After the
282
00:26:47.480 --> 00:26:52.519
cadaver dogs reacted, Chief Peyton abruptly called off the search
283
00:26:53.160 --> 00:26:58.880
for the night, citing darkness or safety, no one's quite
284
00:26:59.000 --> 00:27:06.319
sure why. Shockingly, he also left the sight unguarded overnight.
285
00:27:07.319 --> 00:27:11.880
In other words, the one place on Earth that might
286
00:27:12.119 --> 00:27:19.160
contain Carrie Culberson's remains was left open and unwatched, even
287
00:27:19.279 --> 00:27:24.480
after a strong indication of human scent had been found.
288
00:27:26.279 --> 00:27:30.319
By the time law enforcement returned and drained the pond
289
00:27:30.440 --> 00:27:36.359
the next day, it was perhaps too late. They found
290
00:27:36.519 --> 00:27:40.559
only a set of footprints sunk into the pond's muddy
291
00:27:40.640 --> 00:27:46.279
bottom and no body. It looked for all the world,
292
00:27:46.759 --> 00:27:50.160
as if some one had waded into the muck to
293
00:27:50.279 --> 00:27:58.519
retrieve and remove something or some one during the unguarded night.
294
00:28:00.119 --> 00:28:06.319
Investigators were horrified. The prime opportunity to recover Carrie or
295
00:28:06.960 --> 00:28:12.000
evidence of her fate from that pond had slipped right
296
00:28:12.079 --> 00:28:16.720
through their fingers, and it appeared to Carrie's family at
297
00:28:16.799 --> 00:28:23.119
least that the police chief's negligence or collusion had enabled
298
00:28:23.160 --> 00:28:30.000
the perpetrators to cover their tracks. As days turned to weeks,
299
00:28:30.279 --> 00:28:35.240
the case intensified. The Clinton County Sheriff's office and state
300
00:28:35.319 --> 00:28:40.519
investigators took on a larger role given the conflicts of
301
00:28:40.599 --> 00:28:46.200
interest in the tiny Blanchester police department. Evidence against Vincent
302
00:28:46.279 --> 00:28:52.000
Dowan continued to mount even without a body. Neighbors like
303
00:28:52.079 --> 00:28:56.240
Lanyard and Brown gave statements about what they saw that night,
304
00:28:57.119 --> 00:29:01.279
the car leaving without lights, the assault in the yard.
305
00:29:02.039 --> 00:29:07.240
Friends recounted Vince's history of abuse and how Carrie feared
306
00:29:07.880 --> 00:29:13.119
for her life. Carrie's own mother, Debbie, told police about
307
00:29:13.240 --> 00:29:22.039
Vincent's shifting stories on August twenty ninth, which looked highly suspicious.
308
00:29:22.079 --> 00:29:28.240
It became painfully clear to investigators that Carrie had likely
309
00:29:28.319 --> 00:29:33.279
been murdered that night, and that Vincent, possibly with help
310
00:29:33.599 --> 00:29:38.279
from his half brother Tracy, and others, had disposed of
311
00:29:38.319 --> 00:29:45.160
her body and her car in some unknown location. By
312
00:29:45.240 --> 00:29:50.359
early September nineteen ninety six, the focus of the investigation
313
00:29:50.920 --> 00:29:55.720
had fully turned toward Vincent Dowan. He was officially named
314
00:29:55.720 --> 00:30:00.480
a suspect and a grand jury convened to hear evidence.
315
00:30:01.519 --> 00:30:06.319
Facing mounting pressure, the local authorities could no longer shield
316
00:30:06.599 --> 00:30:11.920
their friend's son. In November nineteen ninety six, a grand
317
00:30:12.000 --> 00:30:16.759
jury in Clinton County indicted Vincent Dowan, initially on a
318
00:30:16.880 --> 00:30:21.319
charge of kidnapping. Since no body had been found to
319
00:30:21.440 --> 00:30:27.759
prove a murder, even without Carrie's body, prosecutors were determined
320
00:30:28.279 --> 00:30:34.480
to pursue justice. As one reporter later noted, Carrie's disappearance
321
00:30:34.680 --> 00:30:39.000
was eventually ruled a homicide, even though her body was
322
00:30:39.039 --> 00:30:44.160
never found. The case was building momentum, and soon it
323
00:30:44.200 --> 00:30:48.519
would head to a dramatic trial, one that would test
324
00:30:48.559 --> 00:30:53.720
the limits of prosecuting a murder without a body. In
325
00:30:53.839 --> 00:30:58.799
July nineteen ninety seven, the eyes of the region and
326
00:30:59.039 --> 00:31:06.240
soon the nation, turned to the Clinton County Courthouse in Wilmington, Ohio,
327
00:31:06.319 --> 00:31:12.440
where Vincent Dowan's murder trial began. It had been nearly
328
00:31:12.519 --> 00:31:18.920
a year since Carrie vanished. The prosecution faced a daunting
329
00:31:19.119 --> 00:31:24.319
task convince a jury that Carrie was dead and that
330
00:31:24.480 --> 00:31:30.440
Doan killed her, all without a body, without a murder weapon,
331
00:31:31.240 --> 00:31:37.680
and without forensic certainty. It was a circumstantial case, but
332
00:31:37.799 --> 00:31:43.440
it was also a compelling one. Over weeks of testimony,
333
00:31:43.880 --> 00:31:49.960
prosecutors presented a mosaic of evidence that peace by Peace
334
00:31:50.759 --> 00:31:55.519
painted a chilling portrait of what likely happened on that
335
00:31:55.640 --> 00:32:01.960
August night. They argued of two possible motive, either of
336
00:32:02.039 --> 00:32:08.440
which or both could explain the crime. One theory was
337
00:32:08.480 --> 00:32:14.000
that Vincent Dowan, obsessively jealous and enraged that he could
338
00:32:14.039 --> 00:32:19.400
no longer control Carrie, murdered her in a final act
339
00:32:19.559 --> 00:32:24.880
of domination. The other theory was that he killed her
340
00:32:25.440 --> 00:32:29.359
to stop her from testifying against him on the assault
341
00:32:29.440 --> 00:32:35.720
charge scheduled in court the following week. In either scenario,
342
00:32:36.119 --> 00:32:39.640
the threat to his control was Carrie's intent to leave
343
00:32:39.720 --> 00:32:46.079
him for good, and Vincent acted on his oft repeated ultimatum.
344
00:32:46.440 --> 00:32:58.000
If he couldn't have her, nobody could. One by one,
345
00:32:58.680 --> 00:33:03.079
witnesses took the band to recount the events surrounding the
346
00:33:03.160 --> 00:33:10.079
disappearance and Dowan's prior acts of violence. Jessica Williams described
347
00:33:10.119 --> 00:33:14.359
the volleyball game on August twenty eighth, explaining how Dowan
348
00:33:14.519 --> 00:33:21.000
showed up unannounced, angry and demanding, and how Carrie stood
349
00:33:21.039 --> 00:33:27.200
her ground, refusing to leave with him. Neighbor Kimberly Lanyard
350
00:33:27.240 --> 00:33:32.119
testified about seeing Carrie's car leave her house around midnight
351
00:33:32.519 --> 00:33:40.039
without its lights on, an eerie detail suggesting stealth or duress.
352
00:33:40.720 --> 00:33:44.799
Then Billy Joe Brown riveted the courtroom with her eyewitness
353
00:33:44.839 --> 00:33:49.799
account of the fight in her front yard, how she
354
00:33:49.880 --> 00:33:55.720
saw Carrie running and screaming help me, and her Dowan bellow.
355
00:33:56.519 --> 00:33:58.880
I told you if you ever tried to leave me,
356
00:33:59.039 --> 00:34:04.720
I'd kill you, you bitch, as he beat her. Brown
357
00:34:04.799 --> 00:34:08.280
admitted she had no phone to call the police that night,
358
00:34:08.920 --> 00:34:13.519
and that her own husband initially dismissed the commotion as
359
00:34:13.599 --> 00:34:19.199
simply a drunken squabble. By the time she realized something
360
00:34:19.320 --> 00:34:26.800
truly heinous was happening, Carrie and Dowan were gone. The
361
00:34:26.880 --> 00:34:32.000
prosecution didn't stop at the disappearance. They traced what they
362
00:34:32.079 --> 00:34:38.440
believed happened in the hours after. Vicky Watson and Laurie Baker,
363
00:34:38.679 --> 00:34:44.719
relatives by marriage to Don's half brother Tracy, provided key testimony.
364
00:34:45.760 --> 00:34:49.639
Watson said she was sleeping over at Tracy Baker's house,
365
00:34:50.159 --> 00:34:55.119
Vincent's half brother, that night at three fifteen a m.
366
00:34:55.840 --> 00:35:00.440
She was awakened by a knock peeking through the blonde.
367
00:35:01.000 --> 00:35:07.280
She saw Vincent Dowan on the back deck, shirtless, looking disheveled,
368
00:35:07.880 --> 00:35:12.199
with his right hand clutching his left arm as if injured.
369
00:35:13.360 --> 00:35:18.000
He was talking to Tracy outside, but Watson couldn't hear
370
00:35:18.039 --> 00:35:24.400
the words. She did notice something peculiar. Dowan's hair was
371
00:35:24.519 --> 00:35:30.000
messy and he appeared agitated, but she saw no visible
372
00:35:30.079 --> 00:35:37.039
blood on him at that moment. Watson didn't intervene. Shortly after,
373
00:35:37.239 --> 00:35:42.559
Tracy's wife, Laurie Baker, drove Watson to work very early
374
00:35:43.440 --> 00:35:50.320
around four am, leaving the two men alone. Laurie Baker
375
00:35:50.440 --> 00:35:57.039
herself testified next, filling in crucial gaps. She confirmed that
376
00:35:57.199 --> 00:36:04.000
Vincent arrived around three point fifteen wearing only jeans, shirtless
377
00:36:04.800 --> 00:36:10.360
and smeared with blood across his chest. He was holding
378
00:36:10.400 --> 00:36:14.679
his arm as if hurt. Laurie recounted that Vincent and
379
00:36:14.719 --> 00:36:20.920
her husband, Tracy spoke in low urgent tones. Then Tracy
380
00:36:21.039 --> 00:36:26.159
came inside to grab trash bags. Vincent took a shower
381
00:36:26.199 --> 00:36:32.119
in her bathroom, washing off something one can only imagine what,
382
00:36:33.280 --> 00:36:36.079
and the two men left the house around three point
383
00:36:36.119 --> 00:36:42.000
thirty or three forty five am, carrying garbage bags and
384
00:36:42.079 --> 00:36:48.559
a gun. When they returned before dawn, roughly five am.
385
00:36:49.079 --> 00:36:54.239
Both men had blood on their clothes and boots. Laurie
386
00:36:54.280 --> 00:36:58.559
testified that she handed Tracy bleach and a scrub brush
387
00:36:59.280 --> 00:37:03.719
and watch as he delivered them to Vincent, who immediately
388
00:37:04.320 --> 00:37:10.039
went to shower. Yet again, she even saw Tracy wiping
389
00:37:10.079 --> 00:37:14.360
off blood from his boots with a rag. It was
390
00:37:14.440 --> 00:37:19.960
a grim clean up scene, bleach, water and blood swirling
391
00:37:20.039 --> 00:37:28.199
away as dawn broke. Investigators later recovered some of Tracy's boots, towels,
392
00:37:28.639 --> 00:37:33.480
and his truck. Testing found blood on them, but it
393
00:37:33.559 --> 00:37:38.800
was too degraded to identify a definitive match. To carry
394
00:37:40.559 --> 00:37:45.760
through these witnesses, the prosecutors effectively walked the jury through
395
00:37:45.800 --> 00:37:51.559
a timeline of murder and cover up. The confrontation around
396
00:37:51.599 --> 00:37:56.079
twelve thirty am, the likely killing and hiding of Carrie's
397
00:37:56.119 --> 00:38:00.840
body somewhere soon after, and the convening of Vincent and
398
00:38:00.920 --> 00:38:05.440
Tracy in the pre dawn hours to dispose of evidence,
399
00:38:06.199 --> 00:38:11.360
presumably moving Carrie's body, perhaps initially hidden in that pond
400
00:38:11.960 --> 00:38:18.679
or elsewhere, to a more permanent location, and disposing of
401
00:38:18.719 --> 00:38:24.599
her car. The red Honda CRX has never been found.
402
00:38:25.079 --> 00:38:31.199
Prosecutors implied it may have been dismantled or crushed, perhaps
403
00:38:31.280 --> 00:38:36.320
hinting at the involvement of the Dowan family junkyard, the
404
00:38:36.360 --> 00:38:44.239
same place that spawned the macabre rumors. Beyond the immediate crime,
405
00:38:44.440 --> 00:38:49.360
the state presented evidence of Dowan's pattern of brutality to
406
00:38:49.599 --> 00:38:56.199
establish intent and motive. Carrie's friends and coworkers recounted her
407
00:38:56.280 --> 00:39:01.960
black eyes and bruises, establishing that day Owen had consistently
408
00:39:02.119 --> 00:39:08.679
beaten and terrorized her. One particularly chilling piece of testimony
409
00:39:09.239 --> 00:39:14.079
came from Mitchell Epperson, a cellmate who was housed with
410
00:39:14.199 --> 00:39:18.280
Vincent in a county jail in late nineteen ninety six
411
00:39:18.920 --> 00:39:25.800
on an unrelated charge. Epperson recalled casual conversations he had
412
00:39:25.880 --> 00:39:30.519
had with Vincent about women. Vincent bragged in jail that
413
00:39:30.719 --> 00:39:35.519
quote you can't let them walk, You gotta make them pay,
414
00:39:36.480 --> 00:39:43.559
referring to disobedient girlfriends. Even more damning, Dowan allegedly admitted
415
00:39:43.639 --> 00:39:47.920
he would quote lie awake at night and think of
416
00:39:47.960 --> 00:39:54.199
a hundred different ways to kill Carrie before I did. This.
417
00:39:54.440 --> 00:39:59.800
Jaw dropping confession from Doan's own mouth, if true, painted
418
00:39:59.840 --> 00:40:03.760
him as a man who not only could have killed Carrie,
419
00:40:04.639 --> 00:40:10.639
but fantasized about it in advance. It went directly to
420
00:40:10.760 --> 00:40:19.280
the issue of premeditation and intent. Finally, Deborah Culberson, Carrie's mother,
421
00:40:19.760 --> 00:40:25.119
took the stand, providing a poignant bookend to the case.
422
00:40:26.360 --> 00:40:30.519
She confirmed the various stories Vincent had told her on
423
00:40:30.599 --> 00:40:36.239
August twenty nine when she searched for Carrie, highlighting how
424
00:40:36.280 --> 00:40:48.000
his lies had evolved over a single mourning Deborah also
425
00:40:48.039 --> 00:40:53.840
recounted a disturbing conversation she had had with Vincent before
426
00:40:54.159 --> 00:41:01.719
Carrie vanished, wherein he tried to downplay his abuse. Quote,
427
00:41:01.920 --> 00:41:05.360
I've always slapped her around. I never hit her with
428
00:41:05.440 --> 00:41:10.519
my fist. I just slapped her, he told Deborah, as
429
00:41:10.559 --> 00:41:16.320
if this somehow made it acceptable. The court room felt
430
00:41:16.320 --> 00:41:20.360
the weight of Deborah's testimony, the anguish of a mother
431
00:41:20.840 --> 00:41:25.480
who practically knew from day one that Vincent had harmed
432
00:41:25.480 --> 00:41:29.880
her daughter, but who still did not know where her
433
00:41:30.039 --> 00:41:37.039
child's body lay. Vincent Dowan's defense team, for their part,
434
00:41:37.639 --> 00:41:42.599
faced an uphill battle, with so many witnesses painting him
435
00:41:42.679 --> 00:41:47.599
as violent and with no solid alibi. His own accounts
436
00:41:47.639 --> 00:41:52.679
of the night were self contradictory. Their strategy was to
437
00:41:52.800 --> 00:41:58.960
so doubt about whether a murder had even occurred without
438
00:41:58.960 --> 00:42:04.119
a body. Defense argued, who could say Carrie wasn't still
439
00:42:04.159 --> 00:42:10.599
alive somewhere. They floated the idea that perhaps Carrie ran off,
440
00:42:11.440 --> 00:42:14.679
that maybe she'd gotten so fed up with life in
441
00:42:14.760 --> 00:42:20.639
Blanchester and with Vince, that she decided to disappear on
442
00:42:20.760 --> 00:42:24.960
her own. They pointed out that not a single drop
443
00:42:25.039 --> 00:42:30.480
of Carrie's blood had been found, nor any finger prints
444
00:42:30.639 --> 00:42:37.760
or DNA tying Vincent conclusively to a killing. They even
445
00:42:37.960 --> 00:42:42.639
produced a few witnesses, some locals who claimed to have
446
00:42:42.719 --> 00:42:47.199
seen a woman resembling Carrie in the days or weeks
447
00:42:47.719 --> 00:42:52.320
after August twenty eighth, though none of these sightings could
448
00:42:52.360 --> 00:42:57.840
be substantiated and were likely cases of mistaken identity or
449
00:42:58.480 --> 00:43:04.280
false hope. The defense also highlighted that no murder weapon
450
00:43:04.599 --> 00:43:09.079
had been recovered, and that some charges like abuse of
451
00:43:09.119 --> 00:43:15.159
a corpse against Tracy Baker had been dropped precisely because
452
00:43:15.280 --> 00:43:20.199
there was no corpse. Could it be? They urged the
453
00:43:20.320 --> 00:43:26.679
jury that Carrie was out there somewhere alive, but the
454
00:43:26.760 --> 00:43:33.320
prosecution had effectively preempted this argument. They had introduced Carrie's
455
00:43:33.360 --> 00:43:39.119
close friends, who testified that Carrie had not packed any belongings,
456
00:43:39.679 --> 00:43:46.000
taken any money, or contacted anyone, not the behavior of
457
00:43:46.079 --> 00:43:52.639
a voluntary runaway. She also had upcoming plans, a new
458
00:43:52.679 --> 00:43:57.679
career path, and ap pending court case, and had given
459
00:43:57.800 --> 00:44:04.360
every indication to stay in her community, not to flee.
460
00:44:04.920 --> 00:44:09.519
And then there were those powerful witnesses to violence that night.
461
00:44:10.559 --> 00:44:15.320
If Carrie had survived the beating, Brown witnessed, why had
462
00:44:15.360 --> 00:44:21.360
she not surfaced? Everything pointed not to a willing disappearance,
463
00:44:21.960 --> 00:44:28.639
but to a violent end. After two weeks of testimony,
464
00:44:29.239 --> 00:44:33.679
the case went to the jury. The nation waited. The
465
00:44:33.760 --> 00:44:38.199
media had taken keen interest, since trials without a body
466
00:44:38.280 --> 00:44:45.519
were at the time relatively rare and risky for prosecutors. Indeed,
467
00:44:45.639 --> 00:44:49.360
the Culberson case would go on to be featured on
468
00:44:49.599 --> 00:44:54.519
national true crime shows like American Justice and date Line,
469
00:44:55.159 --> 00:45:01.320
precisely because of the no body aspect. The story had
470
00:45:01.400 --> 00:45:06.159
all the elements of a made for TV mystery, except
471
00:45:06.239 --> 00:45:12.800
this was painfully real for those involved. As one local
472
00:45:12.920 --> 00:45:18.639
reporter later noted, the trial drew national attention because Dowan
473
00:45:18.880 --> 00:45:25.000
was convicted despite the absence of a body, something many
474
00:45:25.199 --> 00:45:33.000
jurors find difficult to do. In the deliberation room, twelve jurors,
475
00:45:33.559 --> 00:45:38.880
six men and six women agonized over the evidence for
476
00:45:39.079 --> 00:45:46.159
four days. On August seventh, nineteen ninety seven, they returned
477
00:45:46.880 --> 00:45:54.000
with a verdict. They found Vincent Dowan guilty of aggravated murder,
478
00:45:55.159 --> 00:46:00.639
specifically the court alleging that he killed Carrie in the
479
00:46:00.679 --> 00:46:05.119
commission of kidnapping her, and guilty of three counts of
480
00:46:05.239 --> 00:46:10.480
kidnapping related to the various times he'd abducted or restrained her.
481
00:46:11.880 --> 00:46:15.480
He was actually acquitted on a second murder count, which
482
00:46:15.519 --> 00:46:22.280
had alleged prior calculation and design, essentially premeditation, and on
483
00:46:22.280 --> 00:46:27.400
one additional kidnapping count. The jury seemed to conclude that
484
00:46:28.079 --> 00:46:31.800
while he may not have planned out the murder in advance,
485
00:46:32.960 --> 00:46:40.079
he did intentionally kill her during an abduction. With those convictions,
486
00:46:40.599 --> 00:46:46.519
the maximum sentence was on the table. Dowan faced the
487
00:46:46.559 --> 00:46:53.079
death penalty. A separate sentencing phase followed. In November of
488
00:46:53.199 --> 00:46:59.639
nineteen ninety seven. After hearing further arguments, the jury spared
489
00:46:59.760 --> 00:47:04.559
Vince Saint Owan's life by recommending a sentence of life
490
00:47:04.559 --> 00:47:11.360
in prison without the possibility of parole, rather than execution.
491
00:47:12.559 --> 00:47:17.719
The judge imposed that life sentence. Vincent Dowan, at twenty
492
00:47:17.880 --> 00:47:23.719
five years old, was led away in shackles destined to
493
00:47:23.800 --> 00:47:29.559
spend the rest of his days behind bars. As he
494
00:47:29.719 --> 00:47:35.519
was sentenced, he remained defiant, continuing to proclaim his innocence,
495
00:47:36.280 --> 00:47:41.800
a claim he maintains to this day. But the evidence
496
00:47:41.880 --> 00:47:46.599
and verdict spoke otherwise. In the eyes of the law,
497
00:47:47.199 --> 00:47:52.159
Vincent Dowan had murdered Carrie Culberson, even if he had
498
00:47:52.239 --> 00:47:57.719
gone to extreme lengths to ensure that her body would
499
00:47:57.719 --> 00:48:04.239
never be found. For Carrie's family and friends, the verdict
500
00:48:04.400 --> 00:48:09.639
was a moment of bitter sweet justice in that courtroom,
501
00:48:10.159 --> 00:48:16.119
justice was served, a dangerous man was held accountable, yet
502
00:48:16.280 --> 00:48:21.119
there was no reunion with Carrie, no body to lay
503
00:48:21.159 --> 00:48:26.719
to rest. Debbie Culberson and her family walked out, knowing
504
00:48:27.159 --> 00:48:33.239
Dowan would never hurt anyone again, but also knowing that
505
00:48:33.320 --> 00:48:38.159
their own agonizing quest to find Carrie was not over.
506
00:48:45.239 --> 00:48:49.679
Debbie said later quote, we felt relief that he was
507
00:48:49.719 --> 00:48:57.119
put away, but complete peace. That'll never happen as long
508
00:48:57.159 --> 00:49:03.519
as Carrie remained missing. The case was far from closed.
509
00:49:05.360 --> 00:49:11.079
The aftermath of the trial sent shockwaves through Blanchester and beyond.
510
00:49:12.039 --> 00:49:16.719
In the close knit town, people took sides during the ordeal.
511
00:49:17.840 --> 00:49:22.280
Some couldn't believe a local boy like Vincent could commit
512
00:49:22.800 --> 00:49:28.119
such an atrocity. While others rallied behind the Culberson family51300:49:28.320 --> 00:49:36.719
search for truth, longtime friendships frayed, the community became bitterly divided.51400:49:37.559 --> 00:49:42.840
Quote the wounds of Carrie's disappearance divided the town at51500:49:42.840 --> 00:49:49.039
the time and still run deep today. One resident observed51600:49:49.440 --> 00:49:54.000
eight years later, the village was split over those who51700:49:54.079 --> 00:49:59.719
supported the Culbersons and those who supported Dowan. She said,51800:50:00.840 --> 00:50:05.559
this town hasn't given Carrie's family much respect. They have51900:50:05.639 --> 00:50:11.480
been treated unfairly. It will always be that way. Everybody52000:50:11.559 --> 00:50:17.079
knows everybody's business. It divided the town and I don't52100:50:17.119 --> 00:50:23.000
think it will be fixed. Even after the conviction, rumors52200:50:23.079 --> 00:50:29.360
and suspicions lingered in Blanchester's gossip mills. A few stubborn52300:50:29.440 --> 00:50:34.079
holdouts whispered that carry might have run off, or that52400:50:34.239 --> 00:50:39.960
Vincent was framed, But as the years went on, most52500:50:40.119 --> 00:50:45.559
came to accept the obvious. A horrific crime had occurred52600:50:45.840 --> 00:50:50.840
in their midst, and it had been badly mishandled by52700:50:50.920 --> 00:50:57.239
those sworn to protect the community. Indeed, one of the52800:50:57.239 --> 00:51:02.480
most consequential fallouts from Carrie case was the harsh light52900:51:02.599 --> 00:51:07.039
it shone on law enforcement's failure to protect a domestic53000:51:07.159 --> 00:51:13.800
violence victim. Debbie Culberson, Roger Coulberson, and their surviving daughter,53100:51:13.920 --> 00:51:19.679
Christina were not content to let Blanchester's officials off the hook.53200:51:20.880 --> 00:51:25.559
In nineteen ninety seven, while the criminal case preceded, the53300:51:25.679 --> 00:51:31.239
Culbersons took the extraordinary step of filing a civil lawsuit53400:51:31.840 --> 00:51:37.679
against the Village of Blanchester, its police department, police Chief53500:51:37.800 --> 00:51:43.679
Richard Payton, and members of the Dowan family. They alleged53600:51:43.719 --> 00:51:50.920
a wrongful death and a conspiracy. Essentially that Carrie died53700:51:51.159 --> 00:51:56.559
not only because of Vincent's actions, but also because the53800:51:56.639 --> 00:52:02.960
authorities willfully failed to protect her and then aided in53900:52:03.079 --> 00:52:08.039
covering up the crime. It was a bold and emotionally54000:52:08.239 --> 00:52:13.360
charged move born out of the family's frustration with how54100:52:13.400 --> 00:52:20.239
events had unfolded. Their claims were striking. The lawsuit contended54200:52:20.320 --> 00:52:24.400
that Chief Peyton knew Carrie was in danger, he was54300:52:24.440 --> 00:52:29.639
aware of Vince's prior violence. In fact, as later came54400:52:29.639 --> 00:52:34.079
out in court, Peyton had been explicitly told about multiple54500:52:34.119 --> 00:52:41.159
domestic violence incidents involving Carrie, and yet did nothing meaningful54600:52:41.679 --> 00:52:49.639
to intervene. Worse, after her disappearance, he behaved like en accessory.54700:52:49.760 --> 00:52:54.239
After the fact, as one federal judge put it, by54800:52:54.280 --> 00:52:58.639
tipping off the suspect's family and failure to secure the54900:52:58.719 --> 00:53:04.280
crime scene. In one blistering court order, U. S. District55000:53:04.360 --> 00:53:10.239
Judge s Arthur Spiegel wrote that Peyton had violated his55100:53:10.480 --> 00:53:14.960
duty as the chief law enforcement officer and may have55200:53:15.039 --> 00:53:20.480
been quote explicitly or implicitly involved in the cover up55300:53:20.840 --> 00:53:27.280
of Carrie's murder and disposal of her body. The family's attorney,55400:53:27.400 --> 00:53:33.360
Jennifer Branch, argued that Blanchester's officials had learned nothing from55500:53:33.400 --> 00:53:38.639
the tragedy. Quote from the citizen's point of view, the55600:53:38.679 --> 00:53:43.920
police allowed their neighbor to be murdered, they failed to55700:53:44.000 --> 00:53:48.639
protect her. Branch said, what the village learned from this55800:53:48.840 --> 00:53:53.880
incident was how to protect their police chief, not how55900:53:53.920 --> 00:53:58.519
to protect their citizens. The village did not enforce its56000:53:58.559 --> 00:54:06.159
domestic violence law, and unfortunately that has not changed. It56100:54:06.239 --> 00:54:10.840
was a stark indictment of the entire system that had56200:54:10.920 --> 00:54:17.119
let carry down. The civil case dragged on for years56300:54:17.840 --> 00:54:23.480
through legal twists and turns. At one point, Blanchester tried56400:54:23.519 --> 00:54:27.119
to get it thrown out, but parts of the lawsuit56500:54:27.519 --> 00:54:32.679
were allowed to proceed. The culbersins were determined not just56600:54:32.800 --> 00:54:38.480
to recover damages for their pain, but to force changes56700:54:38.960 --> 00:54:43.000
so that no other family in their town would endure56800:54:43.639 --> 00:54:49.079
what they did. By two thousand and one, five years56900:54:49.119 --> 00:54:54.320
after Carrie's death, the village decided to settle and avoid57000:54:54.360 --> 00:54:59.440
a federal trial that would air all of its dirty laundry.57100:55:00.519 --> 00:55:04.559
In a settlement reached in January of two thousand one,57200:55:04.679 --> 00:55:08.559
the village of Blanchester agreed to pay the Culberson family57300:55:09.320 --> 00:55:14.920
two million dollars. More importantly to the family, the village57400:55:14.960 --> 00:55:20.119
also pledged to institute reforms. They promised to establish a57500:55:20.199 --> 00:55:25.440
memorial to domestic violence victims in Carrie's name, and to57600:55:25.639 --> 00:55:31.199
ensure that all law enforcement officers receive further training in57700:55:31.320 --> 00:55:39.360
handling domestic violence cases. In effect, Blanchester's authorities tacitly acknowledged57800:55:39.920 --> 00:55:45.800
that they had failed carry and that change was indeed needed.57900:55:47.199 --> 00:55:52.519
As part of the settlement's non monetary terms, Blanchester unveiled58000:55:52.559 --> 00:55:57.159
plans for a permanent memorial to carry at the municipal building,58100:55:57.760 --> 00:56:01.320
a place where the community could re remember her and58200:56:01.360 --> 00:56:05.039
where her mother could find a small measure of peace.58300:56:12.639 --> 00:56:16.199
On a rainy day in April of two thousand four,58400:56:16.920 --> 00:56:22.760
townspeople gathered in drizzle. To dedicate that memorial at the58500:56:22.800 --> 00:56:26.440
front lawn of the village hall, they placed a large58600:56:26.519 --> 00:56:31.800
stone engraved with an image of angels and the words58700:56:31.840 --> 00:56:37.960
dedicated to the life of Clarissa Anne Carrie Culberson. Next58800:56:37.960 --> 00:56:42.280
to it, a five foot tall bronze statue was installed,58900:56:43.000 --> 00:56:47.800
depicting a young woman in a flowing dress. At the59000:56:47.840 --> 00:56:53.920
statue's base, the word hope is inscribed in bold letters,59100:56:55.440 --> 00:56:59.920
a message as much for the future as for the past.59200:57:01.119 --> 00:57:13.519
Surrounding it are large rocks, each carved with values like faith, awareness, courage, justice, respect,59300:57:13.920 --> 00:57:21.519
love and support. It is, in essence, a monument not59400:57:21.639 --> 00:57:26.880
only to carry but to all victims of domestic violence,59500:57:27.760 --> 00:57:33.719
a physical reminder that such tragedies must not be allowed59600:57:34.519 --> 00:57:42.519
to happen again. For Debbie Culberson, the memorial was deeply meaningful,59700:57:42.519 --> 00:57:48.800
but also bitter sweet. Quote she doesn't have any closure,59800:57:49.519 --> 00:57:53.760
a friend of Debbie's said at the dedication, she doesn't59900:57:53.760 --> 00:57:58.480
have anywhere to go. We go to the cemetery. Where60000:57:58.519 --> 00:58:04.679
does she go? The memorial became that place, a surrogate60100:58:04.760 --> 00:58:08.400
grave where a mother could go to grieve the daughter60200:58:09.320 --> 00:58:13.519
that she couldn't bury. On the eve of the dedication,60300:58:14.440 --> 00:58:19.400
Mayor Tom White observed Debbi at the sight, tenderly arranging60400:58:19.480 --> 00:58:25.400
those engraved stones around the statue. Quote, I would like60500:58:25.480 --> 00:58:29.960
to see something found that can give Debbi closure. The60600:58:30.039 --> 00:58:33.920
mayor admitted, it would be closure for the town too.60700:58:35.000 --> 00:58:38.519
There are a few people out there that maybe don't60800:58:38.519 --> 00:58:43.119
believe she's dead. They never found a body. It would60900:58:43.199 --> 00:58:49.719
be closure for everyone. The memorial therefore stood as a61000:58:49.800 --> 00:58:57.400
symbol for both remembrance and the unresolved nature of the loss. Meanwhile,61100:58:57.880 --> 00:59:04.480
Chief Peyton faced his own reckoning, albeit a mild one.61200:59:04.559 --> 00:59:09.880
He was charged in state court with multiple felonies, including61300:59:09.960 --> 00:59:16.880
obstruction of justice, for his actions during the investigation. In61400:59:16.960 --> 00:59:22.360
a controversial plea deal, those were reduced to misdemeanor dereliction61500:59:22.519 --> 00:59:28.159
of duty charges, to which Peyton pleaded no contest. He61600:59:28.320 --> 00:59:32.239
was convicted and given a slap on the wrist, a61700:59:32.320 --> 00:59:39.920
short suspended jail sentence, a fine, and probation. Outraged residents61800:59:40.159 --> 00:59:45.159
watched as Peyton was allowed to quietly retire from the61900:59:45.199 --> 00:59:51.920
police force. In fact, as Deborah Culberson later testified to Congress,62000:59:51.920 --> 00:59:55.960
Peyton was even granted a year's back pay and his62100:59:56.079 --> 01:00:01.920
accumulated sick leave roughly eighty six thousand dollars to pad62201:00:02.000 --> 01:00:07.880
his pension, essentially rewarding him as he exited in disgrace62301:00:09.079 --> 01:00:13.280
to Carrie's family, This was an insult added to injury62401:00:13.880 --> 01:00:17.199
that the man they believed helped cover up her murder62501:00:17.800 --> 01:00:22.760
got to ride off into the sunset with benefits. But62601:00:22.880 --> 01:00:28.400
at least he was no longer wearing a badge. If62701:00:28.480 --> 01:00:32.199
any good could come out of such a nightmare, it62801:00:32.400 --> 01:00:38.840
was that Carrie's case sparked change. Debbie Culberson transformed her62901:00:38.920 --> 01:00:43.960
grief into activism. She became a leading voice on the63001:00:44.000 --> 01:00:48.840
Clinton County Domestic Violence Task Force, which was formed around63101:00:48.880 --> 01:00:53.960
the time of Carrie's disappearance. Debbie worked with social workers63201:00:54.000 --> 01:00:58.920
and law enforcement on developing better protocols and training for63301:00:59.039 --> 01:01:04.360
handling domestic violence calls. Quote Debi helped to draw up63401:01:04.400 --> 01:01:09.000
the protocol and police training, said one task force member,63501:01:09.800 --> 01:01:13.519
underscoring how the woman who had lost her daughter was63601:01:13.599 --> 01:01:18.440
determined to save others. This was part of a broader63701:01:18.599 --> 01:01:22.559
trend in the late nineteen nineties and early two thousands,63801:01:23.280 --> 01:01:28.679
communities across America were pushing police and courts to take63901:01:28.760 --> 01:01:35.039
domestic violence more seriously. In Ohio and many other states,64001:01:35.679 --> 01:01:42.079
laws and policies were strengthened. For example, many jurisdictions adopted64101:01:42.199 --> 01:01:48.280
mandatory arrest policies for domestic violence calls and better enforcement64201:01:48.760 --> 01:01:54.840
of restraining orders. Nationally, experts noted huge changes in criminal64301:01:55.000 --> 01:02:01.119
justice procedures for domestic violence during that era, though Carrie's64401:02:01.199 --> 01:02:07.440
case showed how those changes hadn't permeated everywhere. The lawsuit64501:02:07.519 --> 01:02:13.320
the Culbersons brought was one of several groundbreaking cases seeking64601:02:13.360 --> 01:02:18.760
to hold law enforcement accountable for failing victims of abuse.64701:02:20.000 --> 01:02:26.199
The message was clear, ignoring domestic violence has consequences and64801:02:26.360 --> 01:02:32.480
police have a duty to protect the vulnerable, not to64901:02:32.559 --> 01:02:37.559
look the other way. The legal precedent set by Carrie's65001:02:37.679 --> 01:02:43.280
case also had a profound implication in criminal law. It65101:02:43.440 --> 01:02:49.360
proved that a no body homicide case could succeed. Historically,65201:02:49.880 --> 01:02:54.679
prosecutors were wary of bringing murder charges without a corpse,65301:02:55.400 --> 01:03:01.079
subscribing to the old adage no body, no murder. But65401:03:01.920 --> 01:03:06.920
Kerrey's trial became a textbook example that if the circumstantial65501:03:07.000 --> 01:03:12.079
evidence is strong enough, a jury can be convinced beyond65601:03:12.159 --> 01:03:18.800
a reasonable doubt of murder even without physical remains. The65701:03:18.840 --> 01:03:23.559
conviction of Vincent Dowan in nineteen ninety seven, joined a65801:03:23.639 --> 01:03:31.119
growing list of cases that emboldened prosecutors nationwide. It demonstrated65901:03:31.280 --> 01:03:37.320
that advances in forensic science, eyewitness testimony, and defendant behavior66001:03:37.400 --> 01:03:43.639
analysis could together establish the corpus delicti, or proof of66101:03:43.679 --> 01:03:49.800
a crime without the victim's body. This case has since66201:03:49.920 --> 01:03:54.679
been cited in law enforcement trainings and by other prosecutors66301:03:55.159 --> 01:04:01.280
to justify pursuing charges in similar heartbreaking scenario where a66401:04:01.320 --> 01:04:06.320
body is missing but evidence of foul play is overwhelming.66501:04:14.440 --> 01:04:21.800
Ohio in particular, took note the successful prosecution signaled to66601:04:21.880 --> 01:04:25.719
would be killers that they cannot count on a missing66701:04:25.800 --> 01:04:32.159
body to escape justice. As one legal commentator put it, quote,66801:04:32.880 --> 01:04:37.519
the body and the questions surrounding Carrie's murder have yet66901:04:38.000 --> 01:04:42.840
to be laid to rest. But even so, the courts67001:04:42.920 --> 01:04:48.880
delivered justice to Carrie's killer. Ohio thus joined the ranks67101:04:48.920 --> 01:04:57.519
of jurisdictions proving that no body is no barrier to conviction. Yet,67201:04:58.000 --> 01:05:02.480
for all these legal and so social impacts, the personal67301:05:02.599 --> 01:05:08.440
fallout for Carrie's loved ones was immeasurable. They had won67401:05:08.639 --> 01:05:16.039
some justice, yes, but the emptiness of loss remained. Carrie's father, Roger,67501:05:16.559 --> 01:05:22.360
and sister Christina had to somehow continue living, carrying the67601:05:22.400 --> 01:05:26.840
memory of a daughter and sister who never got to67701:05:26.920 --> 01:05:34.320
fulfill her dreams. Debbie Culberson, in addition to championing domestic67801:05:34.440 --> 01:05:39.960
violence reform, carried the torch for keeping Carrie's memory alive.67901:05:41.199 --> 01:05:47.960
In every interview, every vigil, every birthday that passed, she68001:05:48.159 --> 01:05:52.880
reminded the world that her daughter was more than just68101:05:52.920 --> 01:05:57.559
a crime victim. She was a beloved young woman who68201:05:57.599 --> 01:06:03.039
deserved to be found and laid to rest. Debbie would68301:06:03.079 --> 01:06:07.559
attend support groups for families of the missing and speak68401:06:07.599 --> 01:06:13.440
out for legislation to aid in searching for unidentified remains.68501:06:14.599 --> 01:06:19.840
The Culberson families fight became not only about how Carrie died,68601:06:20.639 --> 01:06:28.559
but also where she was. Where is Carrie Culberson? That68701:06:28.719 --> 01:06:35.360
question has haunted everyone involved in this case since day one.68801:06:35.480 --> 01:06:40.039
Carrie's body has never been found, and neither has her68901:06:40.119 --> 01:06:45.679
Red Honda CRX. The search for both became one of69001:06:45.760 --> 01:06:52.679
the most extensive and frustrating quests in Ohio history, full69101:06:52.719 --> 01:06:58.320
of false leads, fruitless digs, and whispered rumors that only69201:06:58.440 --> 01:07:04.840
compounded the family's anguish. In the immediate aftermath of Vincent69301:07:04.960 --> 01:07:10.360
Dowan's conviction. Authorities hoped that one of the co conspirators,69401:07:10.960 --> 01:07:16.920
perhaps Tracy Baker, might reveal the body's location in exchange69501:07:17.000 --> 01:07:24.039
for leniency, but no such luck. Tracy, convicted of helping69601:07:24.159 --> 01:07:29.960
dispose of evidence, kept his silence, serving his prison term69701:07:30.159 --> 01:07:33.840
without ever giving up the secret of what they did69801:07:33.920 --> 01:07:40.760
with Carrie after that bloody night. Vincent Dowan, for his part,69901:07:41.199 --> 01:07:45.360
invoked his Fifth Amendment rights during the trial on any70001:07:45.519 --> 01:07:51.320
questions about the whereabouts of Carrie's remains, and he has70101:07:51.400 --> 01:07:57.440
steadfastly refused to confess or cooperate in any recovery effort70201:07:58.079 --> 01:08:04.880
in all the years since. Without the perpetrator's cooperation, the70301:08:04.960 --> 01:08:10.000
task fell to law enforcement and Carrie's family to scour70401:08:10.119 --> 01:08:15.000
the region for any trace of her. The initial focal70501:08:15.039 --> 01:08:20.199
point was, of course, the Dowan family pond, which had70601:08:20.279 --> 01:08:25.960
yielded only footprints. Divers and search teams combed it again70701:08:26.760 --> 01:08:33.399
to no avail. Investigators also searched the surrounding property. They70801:08:33.439 --> 01:08:38.680
looked in wells, ditches, woodlands, and junked cars on the70901:08:38.720 --> 01:08:44.000
Doan and Baker properties. There was a nagging fear that71001:08:44.079 --> 01:08:48.199
perhaps Carrie's body had been put through a car crusher71101:08:48.840 --> 01:08:54.960
or burned in a secret makeshift grave, eliminating obvious evidence.71201:08:56.960 --> 01:09:01.159
The lack of blood traces in Vincent's house, it was71301:09:01.560 --> 01:09:07.680
surprisingly clean when police first searched it days later, suggested71401:09:07.800 --> 01:09:12.720
the crime might have occurred outside, lending credence to the71501:09:12.720 --> 01:09:17.680
theory of the pond or elsewhere as the primary scene.71601:09:18.520 --> 01:09:23.560
But it also meant there were no forensic breadcrumbs to follow.71701:09:25.239 --> 01:09:31.399
As weeks turned to months, leeds grew scarce. Carrie's disappearance71801:09:31.520 --> 01:09:38.000
took on an almost urban legend quality. In Blanchester. Children71901:09:38.079 --> 01:09:42.000
on school buses would pass by the junkyard and whisper72001:09:42.119 --> 01:09:47.279
about that lion rumor, an outrageous tale that Carrie's body72101:09:47.680 --> 01:09:51.920
had been thrown to an exotic pet lion supposedly kept72201:09:51.960 --> 01:09:56.960
on the property. Investigators never found any evidence of such72301:09:57.000 --> 01:10:00.880
a creature. It seemed to be the stuff of small72401:10:00.920 --> 01:10:06.960
town myth, a manifestation of the community's darkest fears. Other72501:10:07.119 --> 01:10:11.479
rumors suggested her car had been compacted, or that she72601:10:11.600 --> 01:10:16.800
was buried under a concrete slab somewhere. Each new tip72701:10:17.119 --> 01:10:21.159
that came in was like a tantalizing spark of hope72801:10:21.800 --> 01:10:27.319
for Debbie and her search volunteers, but so many led72901:10:28.000 --> 01:10:34.760
to dead ends. Nonetheless, Debbie Culberson never stopped searching. She73001:10:35.000 --> 01:10:42.760
organized highly publicized searches periodically, sometimes enlisting volunteers by the dozens.73101:10:43.920 --> 01:10:49.439
They trudged through fields and forests, turning over tire dumps,73201:10:49.479 --> 01:10:54.239
and peering into old wells. With each search that ended73301:10:54.279 --> 01:11:01.279
in frustration, Debbie's resolve only grew. Quote, we have been73401:11:01.399 --> 01:11:05.840
cheated out of a proper grave, a proper funeral, all73501:11:05.920 --> 01:11:11.079
the things people need to grieve, she said, articulating the73601:11:11.159 --> 01:11:17.039
cruel limbo in which her family was stuck. Indeed, not73701:11:17.279 --> 01:11:21.399
knowing where your loved one's body lies is its own73801:11:21.560 --> 01:11:27.960
special kind of torment. It means no closure, no final73901:11:28.039 --> 01:11:32.760
good bye. One of the most dramatic search efforts came74001:11:32.880 --> 01:11:37.000
in spring of two thousand and four, nearly eight years74101:11:37.079 --> 01:11:43.239
after Carrie vanished. Investigators got a tip pointing to a74201:11:43.319 --> 01:11:48.119
remote barn on a farm property in Brown County, a74301:11:48.239 --> 01:11:53.840
county adjacent to Clinton. A man named Jared Messer, who74401:11:53.880 --> 01:11:57.520
had once lived at that property and had ties to74501:11:58.199 --> 01:12:05.000
criminal elements, was mentioned. Acting on this lead, authorities deployed74601:12:05.119 --> 01:12:10.760
cadaver dogs to the barn, and one dog signaled positively74701:12:11.479 --> 01:12:25.880
on the concrete floor, Excitement and dread spiked. Could this74801:12:26.640 --> 01:12:32.840
finally be it? The Clinton, Brown and Claremont County Sheriff's offices,74901:12:33.399 --> 01:12:38.399
along with the FBI and Ohio state authorities, swarmed the75001:12:38.520 --> 01:12:44.600
site with backos and forensic experts. On April thirtieth, two75101:12:44.640 --> 01:12:50.039
thousand and four, crews began the arduous task of breaking75201:12:50.119 --> 01:12:56.600
up the barn's concrete slab and digging beneath it. Debbie75301:12:56.680 --> 01:13:00.399
Culberson got a phone call that day while she was75401:13:00.479 --> 01:13:06.840
literally preparing the memorial dedication ceremony for Carrie. She dropped75501:13:06.880 --> 01:13:12.680
everything and raced to the scene. For the next thirteen75601:13:12.880 --> 01:13:18.720
days through Mother's Day, Debbie and Christina Culberson camped out75701:13:18.760 --> 01:13:23.960
at the sight, standing vigil from morning till night. As75801:13:24.039 --> 01:13:31.159
investigators excavated the barn inch by inch, hope hung in75901:13:31.239 --> 01:13:36.520
the air. The media reported on the dig constantly. Quote,76001:13:37.159 --> 01:13:42.039
I'm just doing what I do best, just waiting, Debbie76101:13:42.079 --> 01:13:46.600
said as she stood in the rain watching heavy machinery76201:13:47.159 --> 01:13:51.399
claw at the earth. If it turns out to be Carrie,76301:13:52.039 --> 01:13:56.399
then that's what we want. But if it isn't, we'll76401:13:56.439 --> 01:14:03.760
wait some more. Those words appearized Debbie's endurance, an endless76501:14:04.359 --> 01:14:10.199
patient weight for the truth. When the Brown County Barn76601:14:10.399 --> 01:14:18.520
dig finally concluded, the result was another heartbreaking disappointment. They76701:14:18.600 --> 01:14:24.640
found nothing related to carry, no remains, no scraps of clothing,76801:14:25.479 --> 01:14:31.159
no car parts. The tip had been well intentioned, but76901:14:31.319 --> 01:14:37.199
ultimately false, or worse, perhaps even a cruel prank or77001:14:37.960 --> 01:14:44.079
a jailhouse rumor with no basis. The investigators packed up77101:14:44.079 --> 01:14:50.000
their gear and Debbie went home with empty hands yet again.77201:14:51.399 --> 01:14:55.039
Quote the feelings are just as strong as they were77301:14:55.079 --> 01:15:02.039
eight years ago, she reflected, emotional exhaustion in her voice.77401:15:02.079 --> 01:15:08.039
Over the years, authorities have chased down other leads. At times,77501:15:08.560 --> 01:15:13.680
divers have searched nearby lakes and rivers, and the FBI77601:15:14.079 --> 01:15:18.600
reportedly checked out auto salvage yards for any sign of77701:15:18.760 --> 01:15:23.880
Carrie's Honda. Psychics reached out to the family with visions,77801:15:24.800 --> 01:15:30.479
none that led anywhere. Verifiable cadaver dogs have been taken77901:15:30.520 --> 01:15:35.760
out to various points of interest multiple times, a testament78001:15:35.840 --> 01:15:42.800
to law enforcements continued efforts. Anonymous letters or deathbed confessions78101:15:43.199 --> 01:15:49.399
have surfaced, occasionally hinting at secret burial sites, but none78201:15:49.600 --> 01:15:55.039
have panned out. Even two decades on. Police said they78301:15:55.119 --> 01:16:00.600
still receive the occasional tip quote tips still will come in.78401:16:01.279 --> 01:16:05.560
We still hope to find her, a sheriff's investigator said78501:16:06.079 --> 01:16:11.720
in twoenty and sixteen, reaffirming that the case, while cold,78601:16:12.600 --> 01:16:17.159
is not closed. The absence of a body has also78701:16:17.399 --> 01:16:23.239
had many legal reverberations. For instance, one charge that Tracy78801:16:23.279 --> 01:16:28.920
Baker initially faced was gross abuse of a corpse. He78901:16:29.039 --> 01:16:33.680
was acquitted on that count, not necessarily because he didn't79001:16:33.680 --> 01:16:38.399
do it, but because prosecutors had no corpse to prove it.79101:16:38.439 --> 01:16:45.439
With that strange quirk underscored a broader issue. Without a body,79201:16:46.119 --> 01:16:52.600
certain truths remain legally unprovable. It also meant that Carrie79301:16:52.920 --> 01:16:58.159
could not be declared legally dead for some time. In79401:16:58.279 --> 01:17:03.560
nineteen ninety eight, about two years after she disappeared, a79501:17:03.680 --> 01:17:11.439
court declared Carrie Anne Culberson legally deceased, allowing her family79601:17:11.560 --> 01:17:16.000
to obtain a death certificate. But for Debbie and her79701:17:16.000 --> 01:17:21.359
loved ones, a piece of paper could never substitute for79801:17:21.439 --> 01:17:27.279
physical closure. The community tried to help the Culberson's cope79901:17:27.840 --> 01:17:31.319
with that lack of closure in any way they could.80001:17:32.479 --> 01:17:35.359
We've seen how the memorial gives them a place to80101:17:35.479 --> 01:17:40.880
focus their grief on milestones. Such as Carrie's birthday January80201:17:40.920 --> 01:17:46.840
thirty first, or the anniversary of her disappearance. Friends still80301:17:46.960 --> 01:17:52.199
gather sometimes at the memorial rock or at the Culberson80401:17:52.319 --> 01:17:58.760
home to pray and remember carry. They share stories about80501:17:58.760 --> 01:18:03.640
her laughter, her athletic exploits, and her sense of humor.80601:18:04.640 --> 01:18:08.640
They imagine what she would be like if she were here,80701:18:09.199 --> 01:18:14.000
approaching the age of fifty quote. I wonder how many80801:18:14.079 --> 01:18:18.560
kids she might have, where she might be in her life,80901:18:18.600 --> 01:18:23.399
what she might look like now, mused her close friend Jamie,81001:18:24.239 --> 01:18:29.159
aching with the knowledge that those possibilities were stolen away81101:18:30.760 --> 01:18:34.439
for the people who loved her. Carrie is frozen in81201:18:34.560 --> 01:18:41.520
time at twenty two, forever young, forever out of reach.81301:18:43.479 --> 01:18:48.239
One particularly poignant symbol of hope that endures in Blanchester81401:18:48.760 --> 01:18:52.600
is found in the lobby of the police station. There,81501:18:53.199 --> 01:18:58.039
a plaque with Carrie's picture hangs on the wall, with81601:18:58.119 --> 01:19:04.359
a promise implicit in its presence it will remain until81701:19:04.479 --> 01:19:10.680
Carrie is found. Her youthful face smiles out at the81801:19:10.720 --> 01:19:17.800
officers each day, silently urging them not to forget. It's81901:19:17.840 --> 01:19:22.760
as if Carrie herself is waiting there, asking for the82001:19:22.880 --> 01:19:30.279
truth to finally be uncovered. The plaque's very existence acknowledges82101:19:30.920 --> 01:19:36.319
a harsh reality that her body and the full story82201:19:36.359 --> 01:19:42.000
of her death are still missing, while also serving as82301:19:42.039 --> 01:19:47.199
a constant goad to those in power do not give82401:19:47.319 --> 01:19:52.680
up until she is home. The lack of a body82501:19:52.840 --> 01:19:57.279
has in some ways kept the mystery alive in the82601:19:57.319 --> 01:20:02.199
public imagination. Over the year years, Carrie's story has been82701:20:02.239 --> 01:20:07.560
featured on numerous true crime television programs and podcasts like this,82801:20:08.520 --> 01:20:13.720
often under titles like Where Is Carrie or no Body,82901:20:14.239 --> 01:20:21.560
No Justice. But unlike some other unsolved mysteries, in Carrie's case,83001:20:22.359 --> 01:20:28.479
justice was partially achieved, her killer sits in prison, Yet83101:20:28.760 --> 01:20:34.439
the mystery persists. A case that is at once resolved83201:20:34.800 --> 01:20:40.720
and unresolved. Solved in the courtroom, but unsolved in the83301:20:41.399 --> 01:20:48.079
physical sense. This duality is haunting. There is no grave83401:20:48.199 --> 01:20:51.960
for family and friends to visit, no way to ensure83501:20:52.119 --> 01:20:57.479
Carrie's remains are treated with dignity and respect. Debbie once83601:20:57.720 --> 01:21:03.720
candidly expressed her anguish quote, I have no place to83701:21:03.760 --> 01:21:07.039
go to talk to Carrie. I don't know if she's83801:21:07.119 --> 01:21:11.000
laying in a field or under concrete or in water.83901:21:12.479 --> 01:21:16.119
I just want to bring her home and lay her84001:21:16.159 --> 01:21:22.760
to rest. In those words lies the simple, heart breaking84101:21:22.920 --> 01:21:29.560
wish that has fueled the Culbersins for decades to find84201:21:29.720 --> 01:21:43.920
Carrie and to finally say goodbye. As of today, nearly84301:21:44.039 --> 01:21:48.680
twenty nine years have passed since that fateful August night.84401:21:49.560 --> 01:21:52.920
It is now a given that Vincent Dowan will spend84501:21:53.000 --> 01:21:58.079
the rest of his life in prison. Barring some unforeseen84601:21:58.319 --> 01:22:04.560
legal reversal. He is incarcerated at an Ohio State penitentiary,84701:22:05.520 --> 01:22:11.399
serving a life sentence with no chance of parole. Over84801:22:11.439 --> 01:22:17.720
the years, Dowan exhausted his appeals, State courts upheld his conviction,84901:22:18.439 --> 01:22:24.800
and federal courts denied his petitions. Outside of a miraculous85001:22:24.840 --> 01:22:31.000
confession or new evidence surfacing, Dowan's case is closed in85101:22:31.079 --> 01:22:36.159
the criminal justice system. In prison, he has few headlines85201:22:37.159 --> 01:22:41.239
one bizarre footnote. In two thousand and fifteen, Dowan was85301:22:41.319 --> 01:22:45.279
bitten by a police dog during a disturbance at the prison,85401:22:46.000 --> 01:22:49.439
and later won a seven thousand, five hundred dollars settlement85501:22:49.760 --> 01:22:54.720
for his injuries, a grimly ironic epilogue, as some noted,85601:22:55.359 --> 01:22:59.760
for a man who caused so much injury to others.85701:23:01.399 --> 01:23:06.319
Through it all, Vincent Dowan insists he is innocent. He85801:23:06.359 --> 01:23:12.600
has never wavered from that stance. For many, his protestations85901:23:12.760 --> 01:23:18.159
ring hollow against the massive evidence of his guilt. To86001:23:18.239 --> 01:23:22.880
this day, he has offered no apology, no admission, and86101:23:22.960 --> 01:23:30.319
no information to help locate Carrie. Tracy Baker, Vincent's half brother,86201:23:30.479 --> 01:23:34.199
who helped him that night, served his sentence for obstruction86301:23:34.920 --> 01:23:39.199
and was released in two thousand and five. He returned86401:23:39.239 --> 01:23:44.199
to society and by most accounts, has kept a low profile.86501:23:45.239 --> 01:23:49.359
Lawrence Baker, Vincent's father, lived out the remainder of his86601:23:49.479 --> 01:23:54.680
life under a cloud of suspicion by some, though he86701:23:54.920 --> 01:24:00.520
was acquitted in court. Chief Richard Peyton fad from the86801:24:00.520 --> 01:24:06.000
public eye after his retirement, his name now synonymous, at86901:24:06.079 --> 01:24:11.039
least in Blanchester with a cautionary tale of how not87001:24:11.680 --> 01:24:18.239
to handle a missing person's case in Blanchester. Carrie's absence87101:24:18.359 --> 01:24:22.319
is still felt. She would be forty nine years old now,87201:24:23.079 --> 01:24:27.640
a fact that astonishes her childhood friends, who still picture87301:24:27.720 --> 01:24:32.359
the vivacious twenty two year old with big quote nineties87401:24:32.439 --> 01:24:38.159
hair and a radiant smile. Each year, on January thirty first,87501:24:38.600 --> 01:24:44.800
Debbie Culberson quietly marks Carrie's birthday. Public reaction to Carrie's87601:24:44.840 --> 01:24:49.520
story remains strong, in the area. The case is taught87701:24:49.560 --> 01:24:53.840
in some police academies as part of domestic violence response87801:24:53.920 --> 01:25:00.319
training and investigative procedure. Memorial motorcycle rides and fire ik87901:25:00.520 --> 01:25:05.159
runs have been organized by domestic violence awareness groups in88001:25:05.239 --> 01:25:10.760
her honor. On social media, the Fine Carrie Culberson Facebook88101:25:10.800 --> 01:25:17.319
page continues to share memories and updates, ensuring new generations88201:25:17.760 --> 01:25:23.680
here her story. Strangers occasionally leave comments of support, and88301:25:23.800 --> 01:25:29.119
locals post photos of the memorial statue decorated for the holidays,88401:25:30.239 --> 01:25:35.119
purple ribbons for Domestic Violence Awareness Month, or flowers on88501:25:35.199 --> 01:25:41.039
the anniversary of her disappearance. Crucially, law enforcement has not88601:25:41.199 --> 01:25:47.000
forgotten Carrie either. The Clinton County Sheriff's Office retains open88701:25:47.119 --> 01:25:53.159
case files on her disappearance. Investigators periodically review the evidence88801:25:53.640 --> 01:25:59.039
with fresh eyes, hoping new forensic technology or a changed88901:25:59.159 --> 01:26:05.199
conscience might crack open the location of her remains. There89001:26:05.239 --> 01:26:10.199
have been recent leads, even decades later. In twenty nineteen,89101:26:10.680 --> 01:26:14.600
Deborah Culberson mentioned that letters had been discovered in prisons89201:26:15.079 --> 01:26:20.279
that potentially related to Carrie's case. Those letters were being89301:26:20.359 --> 01:26:25.600
followed up by law enforcement. Debbie didn't divulge details publicly,89401:26:26.279 --> 01:26:30.600
but she said quote The reason I have hope is89501:26:30.680 --> 01:26:34.159
because there are so many law enforcement officials who have89601:26:34.319 --> 01:26:38.680
so much invested in Carrie's case that they won't give89701:26:38.800 --> 01:26:43.840
up even now. Officers who were just rookies back in89801:26:43.960 --> 01:26:48.880
nineteen ninety six have since risen to senior positions and89901:26:49.000 --> 01:26:54.920
carry forward the determination to bring Carrie home as long90001:26:54.960 --> 01:26:59.600
as somebody is willing to dig, search, or listen to90101:26:59.680 --> 01:27:06.640
a tip. Hope remains the case's broader legacy in Ohio's90201:27:06.680 --> 01:27:12.880
domestic violence law reforms is also notable today. The tragedy90301:27:12.920 --> 01:27:18.399
of Carrie Culberson became a rallying point for advocates. In90401:27:18.439 --> 01:27:23.600
the late nineties, Ohio implemented more robust protective order enforcement90501:27:24.159 --> 01:27:28.960
and improved how victims can get help. By the two thousands,90601:27:29.439 --> 01:27:33.319
thanks in part to awareness raised by cases like Carrie's,90701:27:34.039 --> 01:27:39.000
domestic violence training for police became more standardized across the state.90801:27:40.359 --> 01:27:45.199
Ohio also saw the creation of programs to confiscate firearms90901:27:45.199 --> 01:27:50.720
from convicted abusers and better cross agency communication when someone91001:27:50.800 --> 01:27:55.960
with a known violent history like Dowan is involved. While91101:27:56.079 --> 01:28:01.479
no legislation features Carrie's name, her case is frequently cited91201:28:01.520 --> 01:28:06.000
in Ohio Domestic Violence Task Force reports as an example91301:28:06.119 --> 01:28:13.600
of why early intervention and zero tolerance policies are so critical. Essentially,91401:28:14.119 --> 01:28:19.319
Carrie Culberson did not die in Vain. Her story spurred91501:28:19.479 --> 01:28:24.600
changes that have likely saved other lives, as every officer91601:28:24.640 --> 01:28:29.159
in that region now knows to take domestic violence calls91701:28:29.199 --> 01:28:35.039
seriously and to secure potential crime scenes diligently, no matter91801:28:35.119 --> 01:28:41.279
who the suspect may be. In the community of Blanchester,91901:28:41.880 --> 01:28:45.800
time has a way of moving forward, but reminders of92001:28:45.880 --> 01:28:51.479
Carrie's life and loss are ever present. On a corner92101:28:51.520 --> 01:28:56.039
of the Culberson family's property, a tree that Carrie planted92201:28:56.399 --> 01:29:01.840
as a little girl stands tall. The police station lobby92301:29:01.920 --> 01:29:06.680
still bears that plaque of Carrie, a silent exhortation to92401:29:06.800 --> 01:29:11.439
never stop looking. And of course, the memorial sculpture in92501:29:11.520 --> 01:29:15.800
front of the municipal building stands as a permanent testament.92601:29:16.840 --> 01:29:21.000
Town residents drive by it on their daily commutes, some92701:29:21.319 --> 01:29:26.840
perhaps now too young to recall nineteen ninety six, but92801:29:26.960 --> 01:29:31.119
their parents will tell them of the beautiful cheerleader who92901:29:31.159 --> 01:29:35.920
once graced these streets and the tragedy that befell her.93001:29:37.159 --> 01:29:42.920
Carrie's memory is woven into Blanchester's identity, a caution and93101:29:43.000 --> 01:29:54.640
a call for compassion. If you visit the memorial to day,93201:29:55.319 --> 01:29:58.399
you might see fresh flowers laid at the base of93301:29:58.439 --> 01:30:03.520
the statue. Perhaps they were left by Debbie, who often93401:30:03.560 --> 01:30:09.520
stops by, perhaps by a friend or even a compassionate93501:30:09.560 --> 01:30:16.319
stranger moved by Carrie's story. The bronze woman gazes out93601:30:16.359 --> 01:30:22.199
with a patient, hopeful expression at her feet. The stone,93701:30:22.239 --> 01:30:26.760
carved with the word hope catches the morning light. It's93801:30:26.800 --> 01:30:32.680
a hope that has been tested but not extinguished, hope93901:30:32.840 --> 01:30:38.000
that someday someone will come forward, or some clue will94001:30:38.039 --> 01:30:44.840
surface and carry can finally be found. Until that day,94101:30:45.800 --> 01:30:51.600
Carrie Culberson's case remains open in the only way that94201:30:51.800 --> 01:30:57.439
truly matters, open in the hearts of those who seek94301:30:57.680 --> 01:31:04.640
justice and closure for her. They will not rest until94401:31:04.720 --> 01:31:10.880
they bring Carrie home. Terrifying and True is narrated by94501:31:10.960 --> 01:31:14.680
Enrique Kuto. It's executive produced by Rob Fields and bobble94601:31:14.720 --> 01:31:18.640
Toopia dot com and produced by Dan Wilder, with original94701:31:18.680 --> 01:31:21.560
theme music by Ray Mattis. If you have a story94801:31:21.640 --> 01:31:24.479
you think we should cover on Terrifying and True, send94901:31:24.560 --> 01:31:28.159
us an email at Weekly Spooky at gmail dot com,95001:31:28.199 --> 01:31:29.680
and if you want to support us for as little95101:31:29.720 --> 01:31:32.439
as one dollar a month. Go to Weeklyspooky dot com95201:31:32.479 --> 01:31:35.279
slash join. Your support for as little as one dollar95301:31:35.279 --> 01:31:37.840
a month keeps the show going. And speaking of I95401:31:37.840 --> 01:31:39.600
want to say an extra special thank you to our95501:31:39.640 --> 01:31:42.800
Patreon podcast boosters, folks who pay a little bit more95601:31:42.960 --> 01:31:44.319
to hear their name at the end of the show.95701:31:44.479 --> 01:31:48.000
And they are Kate and Lulu, Jessica Fuller, Johnny Nix,95801:31:48.079 --> 01:31:52.119
Jenny Green, Amber Hansford, Brent McCullough, Karen we Met, Jack Kerr,95901:31:52.319 --> 01:31:54.720
and Craig Cohen. Thank you all so much and thank96001:31:54.760 --> 01:31:57.520
you for listening. We'll see you all right here next96101:31:57.560 --> 01:32:01.000
time on Terrifying and True No No