New Here? Find Your First Fright — Start Here →
Weekly Spooky
Weekly Spooky
Scary stories, urban legends, haunted places, cryptids and dark folklore with Henrique Couto. New nightmares throughout the week. Halloween all year long.
Nov. 6, 2019

Caves - Lovers Trapped by Flesh-Eating Creatures in the Dark

Caves - Lovers Trapped by Flesh-Eating Creatures in the Dark

Two young lovers venture deep into the woods to escape their small-town lives, only to find themselves inside a forgotten cave system hiding something ancient and hungry. At first, the darkness reveals strange, adorable creatures—almost like living toys. But their soft fur and innocent eyes conceal something far more terrifying. As the firelight fades and the mewling turns into shrieks, the cave becomes a deathtrap, and their night of secret romance descends into horror.

If you’ve ever feared what lurks in the dark corners of the earth, this story will stay with you long after the last word is spoken.

Weekly Spooky presents Caves by Joe Solmo — a chilling tale of love, secrecy, and monstrous survival beneath the earth.

🎧 LISTEN NOW and subscribe for spine-tingling horror stories every week!

🎉 Unlock exclusive bonus episodes and support the show on Patreon!
👉 WeeklySpooky.com/Join

📬 Contact Us / Submit Your Horror Story!


🎵 Music by Ray Mattis 👉 Check out Ray’s incredible work here !
👨‍💼 Executive Producers: Rob Fields, Bobbletopia.com
🎥 Produced by: Daniel Wilder
🌐 Explore more terrifying tales at: WeeklySpooky.com

Abridged story transcript. Sexualized passages have been omitted or replaced with brief non-explicit editorial summaries in square brackets. This is not a verbatim transcript. Separate host segments and advertising are omitted. Prepared from an automatic transcription; residual transcription errors may remain.

Caves by Joe Solmo. Becky, where are you? Janice asked, trying to peer out of the rain-coated windshield. The downpour was almost too much for the wipers on the 67 Camaro to handle, even on the fastest setting. Janice turned the old AM-FM radio down, silencing the cure's Friday I'm in love. She gripped the handle on the door as the classic muscle car traveled down the dirt road that led seemingly nowhere.

Easy. If you get a scratch on this car, your dad is going to kill you. I still don't know why we couldn't just go to the lake like we normally do, Janice said, scooching her butt on the recently redone black leather seats. You don't have to tell me. I remember when I dropped my ice cream in his 50s Chevy. I couldn't sit for a week, she replied.

Last time at the lake was too close. Out here, no one will see us. I still don't know why you think we should hide it. We're happy together. That's all that matters, Janice said, placing her hand on Becky's shoulder. I think my parents would understand. Maybe yours would, but my father sure wouldn't. To him, I'm still daddy's little girl who should wear pink and like horses and boys.

It's only for a few months. Then we graduate and we can leave this tiny town and start over in a new city. Did you hear back from any of the schools you apply to yet? Becky asked as she navigated the car down the old logging trail. Years of misuse had let some of the underbrush grow back and come close to scraping the custom paint job on her father's prized possession.

How much further is it? [Editorial summary: Janice adjusts her seatbelt.] It's been like 10 years since I've been here, but I don't think it's much further. You remember Veronica? Her mom brought us here hiking once in the Girl Scouts. There are traces of Native American painting and shit on the walls in the caves. It'll be a cool place for us to be alone, Becky said.

Really alone, Janice said, planting a kiss on Becky's cheek. Becky slammed on the brakes, bringing the car to a halt. What's wrong? Don't like my kisses anymore, Janice said playfully. It's not that. We're here, and it's on foot from here anyway, Becky said. We have to walk in this shit, Janice said, looking down at the peep-toe heels she was wearing. You didn't tell me we'd have to walk in the mud to get there.

I got it covered, don't worry, Becky said, and reached into the back seat. [Editorial summary: Becky reaches into the back seat.] A backpack materialized in her hands, and she placed it between them. She drew an old pair of sneakers and socks out of the bag. They shared a shoe size, something they had learned in junior high. They began to wear each other's clothes shortly after, and soon, they found they had feelings for each other.

Being from such a small town, they knew no one would understand, so they kept it quiet, pretending to just be friends, but they were so much more. Janice still remembered the first time they kissed. It was just a dare. They were still hiding their feelings for each other at the time, but as soon as their lips touched, Janice's heart skipped a beat, and it hasn't caught up since.

Becky was her whole life, her reason for getting out of bed every day, and she couldn't wait until they could tell the world, until she could wake up to her soulmate every single day. What would I do without you? Janice asked, and actually meant it. Probably chase after Justine. [Editorial summary: Becky jokes that Janice might find someone else.] You know it's more than just physical, right?

Janice said. She was always afraid that was what Becky thought. She was never good at expressing herself, and sometimes, a quip, usually about sex, was how it came out. I know, babe. Now change those shoes so we can get going, Becky said and killed the engine. She put the keys in a small pouch on the front of the blue backpack. What else do you have in here?

Janice asked as she tied the sneakers. A surprise for us, she said, and reached into the backseat again. This time, Becky pulled out two cheap plastic rain ponchos and a flashlight. The rain was coming down so hard it made the forest look like night had fallen already, even though dusk wasn't for a few more hours yet. Janice opened the door and hopped out, nearly falling onto the muddy forest floor.

A slight scream from the other side of the car let her know Becky wasn't having an easier time. She ran around the front of the car in the driving rain. Where to, my love? Janice said over the sound of the rain pounding onto the metal of the car. Becky pointed towards a gate and headed toward it. She didn't have a key for it, but it was the woods.

You could just walk around it. She hoped once they got into the woods, the trees would protect them from the rain, but the rain proved too much for the leaves above. She was glad she put the backpack on before the poncho. Janice caught up to her and slipped a wet hand into her own. With a squeeze, she led her forbidden lover into the forest based on a ten-year-old memory.

It really isn't that far from here. Maybe twenty minutes? Becky said. There's a big rock that looks like a big ass. Once we see that, we're close. Figured you would like a big ass, Janice said. I like your ass just the way it is. Come on. The faster we get there, the faster we can get dry, Becky said. Odd way to phrase what we have planned, Janice joked.

Ha ha, babe, Becky replied and climbed over a fallen pine. She helped Janice over the slick bark. The cold of the rain was starting to settle in as they hiked the path, and their conversation came to a halt shortly after. The next few minutes went on in silence until they reached a stream that crossed the path. A worn plank of wood crossed it, worn with age and weather.

It looked sketchy as to if the plank would hold for their crossing. Okay, I really remember this. We're almost there. The ass rock should just be up there. We could probably see it from here if the goddamn rain would let up, Becky said. Motion. There was definitely motion. What would be out in this weather? Even the deer have hauled up somewhere, it thought.

It put a furry paw farther onto the thin branch and moved closer for a better view. It looked down on the two shapes as they passed below. A bright yellow. He couldn't place it, but the sounds they made sparked a memory. It took a few minutes for its sluggish brain to access the right path. Hibernation will do that. It did remember a time, last hunting season, where it came across these...

monsters. It cocked its head and watched as they walked towards the natural cave system it called home. It jumped from limb to limb, racing the strange bipedal creatures back to its lair. Here's Ass Rock, just like I said, Becky said. I wish I brought Dad's Polaroid too. Could have gotten a picture with it, she joked. Didn't he just get that? He probably wouldn't have let you take it anyway, Janice said from beside her.

Yeah, you're right. If I remember, there was a bunch of evergreens. Oh, there they are. We're here, Becky said excitedly and took off for the trees. Wait, Janice said and chased after her. There was a moment of panic when she lost sight of Becky. But all was well when she peeked out of the branches of a young pine. Now she could see behind them was a rock wall, about 20 feet tall.

Becky was peeking out from a hole in those rocks. Together, they left the rain for the shelter of the cave. Becky's flashlight came to life, illuminating the stone walls of the cave. It seemed that a tunnel continued back into the ground. On the ground was the ancient remains of a fire pit. Janice noticed as she shed the poncho. "'Now what?' she asked.

"'Now we get a fire going and get dry,' Becky said, pulling some wood and paper from the backpack. "'Oh, you're trying to appeal to the pyro in me, aren't you?' Janice said, pulling her lighter out of her pocket and doing a few test flicks to make sure it still worked. "'I know you so well,' Becky said and took Janice in her arms.

She kissed her, feeling the coldness of her lips from traveling through the woods. Inside and out, Janice responded in a whisper, then shivered. Let's heat this place up, Becky said, and grabbed the lighter from her friend. In a moment, the cave was lit by the orange light of the fire she created. She looked around the wall for the paintings she remembered as a kid, but didn't see them.

She did see some asshole had spray-painted Jack was here, though. She sighed. People just like to ruin stuff. Nothing was going to ruin this trip, though. Their time was too precious together to waste. Becky sat down next to Janice and held her hand. She was glad the warmth was coming back to her lover. [Editorial summary: The couple share a private moment. Unnoticed, a creature slips past their fire and disappears into the tunnel.] Janice, Becky whispered.

[Editorial summary: Becky tells Janice she loves her, then adds more wood to the fire.] Just then, there was a mewling sound. They both froze. Did you hear that? Janice asked. Yeah, what was that? Becky asked. I don't know. You were the goddamn Girl Scout, Janice said, placing a cigarette in her mouth. She lit it and took a long puff. Did it come from farther in the cave?

Well, it wasn't one of us, Becky retorted and grabbed the flashlight, shining it down the tunnel that led to farther in the earth. Two eyes light up in the beam. What the fuck is that? Janice asked. I don't know, Becky said, backing up and slipping her bare feet into her shoes. Is it a bear? Janice said, taking another drag off her cigarette.

It's like a foot off the ground, Becky said, gaining enough courage to take a few steps closer. Well, maybe a baby bear, like a cub or whatever, Janice said. I don't think so, Becky said and crouched down. It's okay. You can come out here. We won't hurt you, she said to the pair of unblinking eyes, watching them. Soon the eyes were joined by another pair.

Then two more. The mewling sound was getting louder and more frequent. The first pair of eyes moved closer, and Becky could finally see the creature that belonged to those eyes. I... I have no idea what it is. Well, besides cute, she said, going to her knees. She set the flashlight down on the stone floor of the cave and patted her thighs. It's okay.

Come on. Are you sure it's a good idea to call to it? Janice asked and crouched next to her lover. Aren't wild animals dangerous? Well, look at it. Does it look dangerous? Becky asked as she looked at the creatures now ten feet away. Its brown and white striped fur illuminated in the flashlight. Its big green eyes made it look like a toy more than a creature.

It kind of looks like one of those red pandas, Janice said in a whisper that was full of wonder. Yeah, I guess so, Becky replied and then held her breath as the creature came closer. The other ones were moving a little closer, too. That dark spot around his mouth kind of looks like... George Michael. I'm gonna call him George. Come here, George, Becky called out.

She held her hand out to the creature. It moved close enough for Becky to feel its whiskers scrape across her fingers. It rubbed its face against her hand and it felt so soft. Then it mulled again. The others behind it mulled in response. Are you okay, Becky? Janice asked. Yeah, this is awesome. The first one mulled again. This time, the others harmonized with the first, and then they all mulled together.

So cute. They remind me of those things in that movie that we went to see when we were ten. That thing that turned into gremlins, Becky said and slowly moved her hand to pet the creature. It's okay, George. Don't be afraid. mongos genie asked mogwais what the hell is a mongo isn't that the guy from blazing saddles becky asked as they both began to laugh oh yeah genie said and put her cigarette out on the cold stone ground she put her hand on becky's shoulder from this angle she watched as her lover picked the animal up and clutched it to her chest it's okay george see she said and petted it Its mewling grew higher in pitch.

The other creatures matched the key change. See Janice? He likes it. Janice's lips parted in a smile. She placed her chin on Becky's shoulder. It is really cute. I wonder how many of them are in this cave. Ouch! Becky said and took her hand off George's back. It had blood on it. What the hell cut me? she asked. Suddenly, all the mewling stopped.

and every creature began to sniff the air. With almost twice the volume as the mewling the creature in her lap screeched showing a row of sharp teeth, Becky backed her head up in confusion, wondering what she did to upset George. Suddenly, spikes shot out of the fur on its back, sides, and forehead. The sharp protrusions easily penetrated Becky's soft flesh. As she fell limpid to her lover's confused arms, she watched as a tide of these animals charged from the darkness, each bearing the same type of teeth that she now felt biting into her legs.

Janice pulled away in horror, looking into the lifeless eyes of her lover, as the creatures devoured her flesh. Her worst fear came true. She was going to be alone for the rest of her life. But at least, that wasn't going to be for very long.